5 ms·
Patreon is fighting the good fight so far, especially with YT promoting more disposable content with every passing day
by raverbashing 9y ago
Patreon is fighting the good fight so far, especially with YT promoting more disposable content with every passing day
- philfrasty 9y agoAre you a Jake Pauler?
- otalp 9y agoWell, YouTube seems to be punishing any mildly controversial topic, so the positive side is that Nazis and other crazy people can't use it as a viable platform, but on the flip side you can't really talk about anything really serious without getting your ad revenue cut.
- tomp 9y agoBy "Nazis" you mean Jordan Peterson? Because it's the likes of him that are getting banned - in his case temporarily, thank god, but non-ultra-leftists without large social following are doomed.
- otalp 9y ago>but non-ultra-leftists without large social following are doomed Completely false, "left" YouTube channels I know of: like Philosophy Tube and Contrapoints are having serious problems with their videos being demonetised and removed. Videos which even mildly critisize capitalism are being demonetised, it's pretty much impossible to run a left wing YouTube channel without Patreon. Virtually all political videos are demonetized. For example, PhilosophyTube wanted to make a relatively straightforward series on the history of Liberalism, but even before uploading the videos was told by YouTube(when he contacted them) that under the new rules videos like that wouldn't qualify for ads(https://twitter.com/PhilosophyTube/status/898261400786657280 https://twitter.com/PhilosophyTube/status/898261400786657280) So you're displaying a huge persecution complex if you think this doesn't apply to the left even more, since Google and advertisers are large corporations, which means they are de facto fine with pro-capitalist content while obviously against helping spread or advertising on anti-capitalist content.
- notahacker 9y agoIt's perfectly possible to run the channel. You're just not going to make any money from it. Can't really blame advertisers for not wanting to associate their brands with political content, especially if it's as toxic as a Jordan Peterson rant on gender, and can question the motives of anyone whose decision on whether to critique capitalism or not is based on whether they can get enough juicy ad dollars for doing so.
- l33tbro 9y agoI thought Peterson was a psych professor who has interesting perspectives on the bible. What are his toxic views on gender? Genuinely curious.
- canoebuilder 9y ago"Toxic" views I suspect along the lines of, It does more harm than good to the individual and society to entertain the delusions of mental health conditions. The condition of gender dysphoria is a personal issue best dealt with between the affected individual and their health care provider. But the key driver for Peterson was that pronouncements on these issues have absolutely no place in the Canadian constitution. I think it was only with this issue(legislative lunacy) that he started discussing this, and it wasn't out of some contempt or animosity for people inclined to dress and behave a particular way, but rather because when societies start legislating what people are and aren't allowed to say and think, things tend to go real bad, real quick. Peterson felt a strong duty to take a stand here due to his long study of the horrors and atrocities of communism the 20th century that often stemmed from mandates imposed on acceptable speech and thought.
- notahacker 9y agoPeterson gained a lot of attention and an entirely new YouTube following for refusing to call transgendered students by their preferred pronoun on the basis it was "mouthing Marxist words" and directly linking it to gulags and mass slaughters Lest one think that this might be an unfortunate bit of hyperbole taken out of context in what must be an unusual situation for an outspoken middle-aged religious intellectual to face, he's doubled down on it with an angry lecture series on the subject and other crackpot theories like "the idea that women were discriminated against across the course of history is appalling" and actually it's all a myth caused by the birth control pill making modern women hostile towards masculine men. I wish I was parodying that argument; I'm merely summarising it. I doubt advertisers were upset by his studies on the Bible
- s73ver_ 9y agoI think those that follow the alt-right overestimate how much others care that they are banned. I remember when loads of them left Twitter for Gab, pronouncing that Twitter was doomed without them. And yet, Twitter hasn't really seen any negative effects of them leaving.
- sschueller 9y agoPatreon is falling into the same problem, banning people who they don't agree with. People are moving all their eggs from Youtube to Patreon.
- raverbashing 9y agoDo you have an example?
- sschueller 9y agoMaybe not the best example but Lauren Southern is one. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rtImwK5TI4g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rtImwK5TI4g
- jerf 9y ago"People are moving all their eggs from Youtube to Patreon." That's less of a concern though, because Patreon is easier to replace than YouTube. The problem with YouTube is that, at least as long as the Internet chatter I hear is still accurate, YouTube itself is still losing money, so replacing YouTube involves being able to immediately hugely subsidize people watching lots of video, and to be willing to do so when it is demonstrated that even the market leader who gets all the good ad contracts is losing money, so there's no payday if you win. That's a tough sell. Patreon can't literally be replaced in the legendary "HN denizen claims to be able to replace $X in a weekend", because dealing with taking payments takes longer than that. But it's feasible down in that range, and said replacement at least has a cash flow and a clear path to ramen profitability. It's gonna be a competitive field and Patreon has all the name advantage right now, but it's a feasible plan for a "true startup" of just a few people in a garage in a way that "let's replace YouTube!" isn't. In fact there's at least three competing services I've heard of that already exist, and I have no reason to believe I've heard of them all.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Patreon can't literally be replaced in the legendary "HN denizen claims to be able to replace $X in a weekend", because dealing with taking payments takes longer than that. Stripe literally has an offering just for this use case: https://stripe.com/connect https://stripe.com/connect Forum + Stripe Connect + CDN for Video (Cloudfront, Fastly, Whatevs) = Patreon replacement. You could literally replace it with a weekend Hackathon.