5 ms·
You can download the malware samples and do forensics yourself. http://contagiodump.blogspot.com.au/2017/02/russian-apt-apt28-collection-of-samples.html http:/
by nl 9y ago
You can download the malware samples and do forensics yourself.
http://contagiodump.blogspot.com.au/2017/02/russian-apt-apt28-collection-of-samples.html http://contagiodump.blogspot.com.au/2017/02/russian-apt-apt2... has the ATP28 samples (do verify the hashes though!)
https://www.fireeye.com/content/dam/fireeye-www/global/en/current-threats/pdfs/rpt-apt28.pdf https://www.fireeye.com/content/dam/fireeye-www/global/en/cu... has the techniques they used to identify developers. I agree it is circumstantial, but it's pretty strong and systemic.
I personally find this more compelling than a pcap which would just show the last jump.
- staunch 9y agoI'm referring to dumps of the hackers themselves, detailing their chat logs, emails, bitcoin transactions, ssh traffic, etc. Not just the exploit-based traffic. If I ran the NSA, I'd have every hacker group I could find under total surveillance. I have video of the moon landings and the testimony of thousands of people that were physically involved.
- losteric 9y ago> I'm referring to dumps of the hackers themselves, detailing their chat logs, emails, bitcoin transactions, ssh traffic, etc. Not just the exploit-based traffic. Do you think this is how the NSA operates? They have that big ol' office building so they can email each other incriminating evidence, pay themselves with bitcoin, and ssh into rooted boxes from government facilities? This is state-sponsored warfare, not script kiddies or hacker gangs.
- staunch 9y agoIt sounds like you're confused...I'm saying the NSA may have chat logs of the hacking group itself. These "hacking groups" range from script kiddies that can barely phish, to world class programmers working with billions in resources. Regardless of who did it, it's entirely possible that the NSA has damning evidence of what went down.
- losteric 9y agoNo, I think you're confused. I pointed out that: * NSA is a top-tier state-sponsored actor. * NSA doesn't leave chat logs, bitcoin transactions, or email logs lying around to be hacked. * Another top-tier state-sponsored actor would act the same way (no chat logs). * If a foreign state was behind those attacks, the NSA would not be able to find chat logs (because they don't exist). * Therefore, your acceptance that the Kremlin was behind the attacks cannot depend on the NSA releasing that kind of evidence. It's paradoxical. The evidence wouldn't exist if that fact held true. Honestly, I would be more suspicious if the NSA released the kind of evidence you were asking for. Not to say it's true or false either. These are spy games, there's never 100% confidence...
- KekDemaga 9y agoMy case as already been said better by others: "In the physical world of crime investigation, common sense dictates that the perpetrator of a crime may use any weapon and not just one made in the country of his birth, and that the developer or manufacturer of the weapon most likely isn’t the criminal. And yet, those seemingly crazy assumptions are made every day by cybersecurity companies involved in incident response and threat intelligence. The malware was written in Russian? It was a Russian who attacked you. Chinese characters in the code? You’ve been hacked by the Peoples Liberation Army." https://medium.com/@jeffreycarr/the-dnc-breach-and-the-hijacking-of-common-sense-20e89dacfc2b https://medium.com/@jeffreycarr/the-dnc-breach-and-the-hijac...
- staunch 9y ago"The person or persons responsible are unknown, but let’s assume that CrowdStrike is correct and the responsible party are Russian hackers employed by one or more of Russia’s intelligence services. They used APT28 malware developed and maintained by a Russian lab." Another out-of-context quote from the same article...this is fun ;-) No informed person is claiming Russia did it merely because it was "written in Russian". They're all basing it on many pieces of circumstantial evidence. Don't crime investigators also look at the criminal history, motivations, and opportunity of the suspect? I'd say you're doing a disservice to that author by taking his quote out of context. He's very clearly not making the simplistic straw man argument that you are. It sounds like he suspects the Russians did it, as is rational, but wants real proof -- and not just circumstantial evidence. That is a totally reasonable demand.
- KekDemaga 9y ago>It sounds like he suspects the Russians did it, as is rational, but wants real proof -- and not just circumstantial evidence. That is a totally reasonable demand. That is all I ask as well. Considering we are accusing a nation with nuclear weapons of an act of war the evidence must be much more than circumstantial. The FBI wasn't even permitted to investigate the server personally yet, let's start there instead of relying on private contractors paid by the DNC.