3 ms·
All good and fine but I think, you are better off learning signals from some other resource as well. It's alright to get started but you would want to learn the
by asyncdork 16y ago
All good and fine but I think, you are better off learning signals from some other resource as well. It's alright to get started but you would want to learn the modern way of doing signals with sigaction(POSIX). IIRC, even the corresponding chapter in this guide mentions this in passing.
- ant5 16y agoEven more so because he doesn't mention the major danger zone of signals -- your code needs to be async-safe: https://www.securecoding.cert.org/confluence/display/seccode/SIG30-C.+Call+only+asynchronous-safe+functions+within+signal+handlers https://www.securecoding.cert.org/confluence/display/seccode... Signal handlers will be called in the middle of execution of another function. There's no way to tell what locks may be held or what resources may be allocated/reserved; you can only safely call functions that have been evaluated to be and declared async-safe. That doesn't give you many options within a signal handler, but it also gives you a very good reason not to use them at all, if you can avoid them. On the BSDs and Mac OS X you can use kevent to handle signals via EVFILT_SIGNAL, which means you can avoid this mess altogether. On Linux, you have signalfd() which will let you monitor a file descriptor combined with select()/epoll()/etc to handle signals.
- beej71 16y agoOk, folks--this is excellent feedback. So... I've updated the page, and it was at the end of a long day, so I've probably introduced a raft of new errors and omissions. Now it's all sigaction() all the time, and there is hardly a mention of signal(). I included the async stuff and added sig_atomic_t info. The complexity of sigaction() et al is pretty high compared to signal(), so I only gave it a glancing blow. I do agree with many posters that there is probably a better way than signals to do whatever it is you're doing. I don't think I've ever used them in real life other than to reap dead children or handle SIGINT. (Of course, people do--it just might not be that common.)
- ant5 16y agoYou're awesome (and the update looks great).
- beej71 16y agoDamn--it's been so long since I looked at it, I'd forgotten I hadn't updated it. Yes, the old signals are crap. I REALLY have to update that section (which, in my defense, was written about 15 years ago.)