4 ms·
Anecdotally, I spent a couple of months this summer going through team selection at Google NYC, with a specific request for back-end, low-level, preferably C++
by geofft 9y ago
Anecdotally, I spent a couple of months this summer going through team selection at Google NYC, with a specific request for back-end, low-level, preferably C++ roles (app security, build systems, etc.). I didn't meet or talk to a single woman through the entire process, with the exception of reception, another candidate, and someone who was covering for my recruiter when he was on vacation. I asked every manager I talked to about diversity on their team, and they all gave wishy-washy answers (at best; one told me that women just weren't interested in his team's work). If I'm remembering right, of the teams that I could have accepted an offer from, exactly one had exactly one woman.
This wasn't the only reason that I ultimately turned down the Google offer (and spent so long in team selection after passing the interview), but it was certainly one of them.
There are some back-end teams at Google that have lots of women; Chrome security comes to mind (I don't know if that's "back-end" in the common sense of the term, but it was the sort of team I was interested in). But I don't find it particularly dubious that these are the exception and not the rule.
- isoskeles 9y agoIf you want to assume something insidious about Google's intentions, am I allowed assume that you just want to find a female coworker to wife?
- brad0 9y agoI'm not really sure what you're trying to achieve with this comment. In saying that I am curious as to why the GP is looking for females specifically in the team.
- isoskeles 9y agoThe person I replied to was implying that the team he was interviewing for was sexist, to an extent where they simply would not hire women. I don't think this is an okay implication to make based on such little information (we're supposed to trust that the people he spoke to were "wishy-washy" about "diversity"), and I'm asking if it's just as okay to question his own intentions.
- geofft 9y ago> The person I replied to was implying that the team he was interviewing for was sexist, to an extent where they simply would not hire women. I am making no such implication. I am simply saying that I don't find it "highly dubious" that Google has extreme levels of gender bias in teams correlated with area, based on some amount of data (looking at basically all the open reqs in backend in Google NYC over a couple months). I do find it worrisome to see "sexist" thrown around so quickly: this is a question of objective fact, and we either need to be comfortable with applying the label "sexist" to lots of scenarios and not interpreting it as equivalent to "morally inferior and execrable", or we need to avoid the label, because otherwise there are chilling effects towards discussions of objective fact. The assertion was made, in the lawsuit, that backend teams at Google do in fact fail to hire women. In order to discuss that, we have to be willing to talk about teams that fail to hire women. That said, if I'm going to support free speech, I should be consistent, and I welcome your attempts to question my own intentions. But to that I would reply that if I was looking for someone to marry, I'd specifically want to avoid them being on my team (even if I'm okay with the ethical breach, conflict-of-interest rules would prevent us from marrying), so joining a company that hires women but not for my field would actually be just what I'd be looking for in this case. Perhaps more factually-tenable aspersions to cast would be that I'm gay and get hopelessly distracted if I'm working with men? That's not true either, but it'd make more sense.
- snovv_crash 9y agoI'm currently trying to hire multiple C++ engineers. We have a quick, simple automated test that we use as a pre-screen, and so far no women have managed to pass this test. Not that I'm actually surprised; the ratio of applicants is also biased about 50:1, and we haven't had 50 people pass the automated test yet.
- geofft 9y agoLet's be clear, I agree that this is hard. (And as mentioned elsewhere in the thread, I ended up joining an all-male team at another company.) But I also want to know that the company is taking the problem seriously. If your ratio of applicants is biased at 50:1, either you're doing something that I'm not super happy with, or more likely, you're trying your best and your recruiting funnel is doing something that I'm not super happy with and your ability to change that is limited -- which, to be clear, is not really your fault, and more the fault of how company politics works and what power you have to fix the recruiting process, but if your company is set up so that you as a hiring manager don't have the power to make your recruiting pipeline better, that says things about your company's management culture / power structure that are a negative indicator to me. (In particular, since I tend to work more in support functions like building platforms than direct profit centers, my management chain having limited political sway in the company is a pretty big concern for my long-term happiness, regardless of the thing they're trying to accomplish with that sway.) If you tell me your recruiting funnel is biased at even 5:1, I'm not going to insist on 1:1. I know it's a hard problem. If you tell me it's biased at 5:1 and you're working to change it, fantastic, that's more than I've heard from most people.
- dontJudge 9y agoYour intent on joining a women-based team is very creepy/cringe. This is not a healthy behavior.
- umanwizard 9y agoIt's not creepy at all to prefer not to work in a 100% male environment.
- geofft 9y agoI didn't ask only about gender; I mention it because that's what the conversation above was about. I was leaving a job where the management structure had not worked well for me (nothing against the people in management, it just wasn't productive for the way I work), so all my questions were about how management worked - and in fact the remainder of my reason for turning down the job offer was that there were lots of other ways in which the management at Google didn't seem like it would work for me, much as there were lots of individual people I liked. My questions about diversity specifically included diversity of gender, race, and background (internal vs. external hires, experienced vs. new hires, etc.), and in part I was listening for how they would answer more than what they answered. My current team at the company I ended up joining, as it happens, has no women, so this clearly isn't a dealbreaker for me - but I was much more convinced by the quality of management on several axes.
- tptacek 9y agoThis is a deeply rude and inappropriate comment for HN, especially given the context. It's not OK to talk to people like that here.
- dang 9y agoThis is a personal attack and you can't comment like that here. Please see the site rules at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. We ban accounts that repeatedly post uncivilly, so it's important not to.