3 ms·
The problem with union negotiations is that members’ ability to earn isn’t related to the merits of the member’s ability. I don’t want to make the same exact wa
by briandear 9y ago
The problem with union negotiations is that members’ ability to earn isn’t related to the merits of the member’s ability. I don’t want to make the same exact wage as someone with the same seniority but perhaps less ambition. I am not an interchangeable widget.
Everyone is not equal in value despite being equal in seniority or experience.
A first year teacher might be amazing, but thanks to unions her wage is codified based on her position in the pecking order and not her merits.
- Frondo 9y agoUnions don't have to pay based on seniority. They are democratically organized, and as such, are structured to reflect the will of their members. Don't want seniority-based pay? Don't set up your union contract that way.
- Spooky23 9y agoThat's the argument of a boss in version of the prisoners dilemma. The reality is that you are a widget, you probably make less several people whom you consider a less able and "ambitious" than you, and your salary is only loosely associated with your value, if at all.
- CryptoPunk 9y agoThat's the class warfare paradigm that boils the world down to two monolithic blocs: employers and employees. He is not a widget. A workforce is made up people with diverse and varying skills. It's in the interest of society to incentivise individual skills development and promotion of people with more skill into positions of greater authority and responsibility, by allowing employers to base compensation and promotion offers on skills.
- Spooky23 9y agoIt's a market. I don't care about society, I care about delivering cash to my shareholders. All business is about repeatable process. Domain experts build a process. The operations people execute. Lather, rinse, repeat. People are nurtured/developed/promoted because it is cheaper to do that than to go back to the market. But, every single individual is expendable and replacable. There may be pain or cost associated with someone leaving, but a viable business will survive. If you think you are essential to your employer, film a little video explaining why, post or save it somewhere and set a calendar entry to visit it again in 5 years. You'll have a good laugh in 5 years.