5 ms·
Were there a publicly-traded company that manufactures small violins (preferably the one that makes "world's smallest"), I'd go long on their stock right now.
by mikestew 9y ago
Were there a publicly-traded company that manufactures small violins (preferably the one that makes "world's smallest"), I'd go long on their stock right now.
I mean, who do they expect to persuade with this? Is there anyone not tied to the adtech industry shouting, "Damn you, Apple, and your assault on open web standards!" 'cuz me, I'm thinking, "without even reading the article, if the ad industry is upset about it, it must be good."
- SomeStupidPoint 9y ago"We routinely send you malware without an iota of shame or responsibility, but how dare you not store for us the tools we need to track, productize, and sell you like livestock!" Is there any reasonable response to this besides, "yeah, go fuck yourself"? This is bullies crying that their victim didn't show up by the flagpole at 3pm for his beating. I sincerely hope they go out of business -- these companies are toxic and canerous. But that's a rant long enough to fill a book.
- pas 9y agoThere is money in "creative communications", money in semi-captive audiences. (Every time you want to read an article that has a hundred ads around it.) There will be people exploiting that. AdBlock works pretty well though. The real problem is that people don't have the intrinsic need of blocking those fucking ads, because they are dumb as fuck :( But we have YouTube and a lot of sites that live off ad revenue. (That search engine thing too, you might have heard about it.)
- proofofstake 9y agoThe end result for the customer is that the ad industry will switch to cross-device tracking for everyone. Right now, you had an option to opt-out, by setting cookies to block. You were relatively safe. Now the default will become a net of machine learning algorithms which can track you cross-device without requiring cookies. It is not possible to safeguard against that, unless you completely randomize your online browsing behavior.
- FabHK 9y agoInteresting point: If the despicable ad industry "ups their game", it might get harder to evade. What techniques exist in that space? Anything beyond browser footprints ( https://panopticlick.eff.org https://panopticlick.eff.org ) and super cookies? Any reasonably realistic suggestions for evading tracking in that scenario?
- ReverseCold 9y agoLearn a few new languages, browse on each device thinking with that language. It could be enough to fool some algorithms.
- proofofstake 9y agoThere is probabilistic vs. deterministic cross-device tracking. Deterministic assigns a unique device identifier to each device and then uses more data to connect device IDs to an individual. Probabilistic cross-device tracking uses machine learning algorithms to match up devices and identities. For this they can use basically any data that you happen to give them, including behavioral data (you check a website both at home and during transit on your mobile phone, you use the mouse to select text during reading an article, you accidentally gave an application access to your location data and they have resold this, etc.). Probabilistic cross-device tracking can work with and without cookies. Of course ad companies employing these techniques for their customers claim very optimistic accuracy, but know that the accuracy is at least accurate enough to provide them with useful tracking data on individuals. This accuracy will go up if you push ad companies in a corner and confront them with a 10% (or whatever marketshare Apple browsers have) non-cookie-able surfers (as opposed to a fringe small sample of users that block cookies and did so for years). When cookies got banned/required permission in Europe, European websites just started buggering everyone to accept cookies before you were able to read what you were coming for. While everyone already had the option to only allow cookies from trusted domains, now everybody gets pestered with giant pop-ups. Companies also switched to server-side analytics/tracking, or started requiring log-in to track you. If cookies were accepted, one could just join a cookie swap program to mess with the advertisers. Probabilistic cross-device tracking is very hard to avoid, as not using javascript and a general browser like TorBrowser is also an informative fingerprint. And you can't realistically change your browsing habits, which exposes you to gender and age identification (they need this to identify individuals in a household using a single IP).
- cfarm 9y agoThere's definitely truth to this. However, website developers who rely on this data to monetize their sites with ads will suffer.
- nevon 9y agoI work on a checkout product that is implemented as a third-party iframe. We set a cookie so that a user can have their information remembered for the next time, so that if you've shopped at merchant A, you won't have to fill out your information again when you want to shop at merchant B or C. We don't use it to track you or profile you, it's literally just to make it easier for you to check out (which makes our merchants happy because they see less drop-off). We have a very simple and obvious way of opting out of this, directly in the checkout itself, if you for whatever reason don't want to be remembered. Unfortunately, because most people don't visit us in a first-party context, we are classified as a tracker, so we can't read our cookie anymore. The result being that our customers have a worse experience. If they want to get prefilled, they'll now have to go through this weird redirect song and dance so that we can interact with them in a first-party context. So yeah, while I'm generally for enhanced privacy, I think this specific implementation is harmful. I think that all it achieves is that it consolidates the ability to track users to a small number of giants that you routinely interact with in a first-party context on a daily basis (Facebook, Google, etc).
- MagerValp 9y agoWhile that sounds user friendly and genuinely useful, to me it's acceptable collateral damage in order to stop the rampant abuse by ad networks. As a user I'm also not sure it's a huge loss, since at least the browsers I use can auto-fill addresses and credit cards.