3 ms·
> I've been thinking about similar things in the context of a basic income. If we were to just pass a law and guarantee a significant basic income I think it wo
by emodendroket 9y ago
> I've been thinking about similar things in the context of a basic income. If we were to just pass a law and guarantee a significant basic income I think it would have disastrous effects and fail miserably. A guaranteed income is a good goal, but before we do that we need to figure out how to replace meaningful employment with other meaningful activities. People need a purpose.
I don't think so. I think people can find a purpose without us imposing one on them.
> If I can get anything I want from a replicator in the wall, what are my incentives to still better myself and work towards something?
Why do people get really good at chess when there is little extrinsic motivation in it? If some people just want to hang around, is that really a "problem" we need to address?
- infinite8s 9y agoDoes maintaining an opioid addiction count as a meaningful purpose? Who's to say it's not (as long as it doesn't harm anyone else)?
- criddell 9y ago> I don't think so. I think people can find a purpose without us imposing one on them. I didn't mean to say a purpose should be imposed. Today it kind of is. A purpose is often closely tied to a job and a job is pretty much required to survive. I was trying to convey that we should look for more ways to help people find a purpose or whatever you want to call some activity that is meaningful and fulfilling to that individual and socially healthy. > If some people just want to hang around, is that really a "problem" we need to address? Maybe, maybe not. If they are hanging around because it's what they want to do and they are happy and healthy doing so, then I don't see a problem.
- emodendroket 9y agoWell you said there shouldn't be a universal basic income because people wouldn't have a purpose without the job being imposed on them, which seems to take as its premise that people need to have some kind of purpose imposed on them. The big reason unemployed people feel purposeless is because we live in a society where everyone is supposed to have a job or else is a drain on society/shamefully failing to support their families/whatever else. In a world where there's no need to have a job to support yourself who's to say that's still the case? That's not to say there aren't other potential problems, but I'm not sure "purpose" is the real one.
- criddell 9y ago> I'm not sure "purpose" is the real one Purpose might not be the right word. I think people need meaningful lives.
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, no, I think that's the right word to convey that. I don't see life as meaningful because of the amount of time I spent at my job really.