3 ms·
> In a dream, none of the phenomena I experience (colored blobs moving about) correspond to any facts about an external reality. I think it does. Unless you se
by naasking 9y ago
> In a dream, none of the phenomena I experience (colored blobs moving about) correspond to any facts about an external reality.
I think it does. Unless you seriously think you dream before you've ever had a single experience? Dreams are memory mashups.
> When you're having a dream, it is all an illusion (of the first kind), but to conclude that you are therefore not experiencing anything whatsoever and thus there's nothing to explain would be a grave mistake.
I've already acknowledged that humans "experience" things, in a colloquial sense.
What's left to explain is whether it's possible to capture what we term "experience" using third-person objective facts. We still need an account of how this happens, so there's plenty left to explain.
- monktastic1 9y ago> I've already acknowledged that humans "experience" things, in a colloquial sense. Thanks for the clarification. Perhaps we don't disagree in the way I thought. Let me see if I understand our divergence. Because my experiences have a certain consistency, I infer an objective cause. Because this continues to happen, I become increasingly certain about this model (e.g., materialism). In brief, the way I model reality is the result of a particular configuration of experiences. I then use this model to explain the existence of experience itself. So far I hope we're on the same page. Where I think the divergence happens is in whether a person considers the inferred model (materialism) or the "sheer phenomenon" (colloquially, "experience") to be more fundamental. I think I understand (and respect) why you and others feel it should be the former. Being the sort of person who spends time relaxing my inferences about reality (i.e., "meditating"), I feel it's the latter. Anyway, I should probably go spend time doing something else. Apologies if I've mischaracterized your views.