6 ms·
> Android -> iOS this one surprised me to say the least. It's like jumping from the dragon's mouth into the lion's pit. Both are not good options for privacy,
by ekianjo 9y ago
> Android -> iOS
this one surprised me to say the least. It's like jumping from the dragon's mouth into the lion's pit. Both are not good options for privacy, you have no knowledge of what Apple collects and what it does with your data either and it basically requires you to have an iTunes account. At least on Android you can install other app stores like Freedroid which are not linked to any major vendor.
- r3bl 9y agoWell, the article in question is "life without Google". iOS is not Google's. Therefore, it satisfies the point of this article. While I do agree that Apple is no better at preserving privacy, it doesn't fit the scope of this article.
- ekianjo 9y agoThis is not the point. The reason why they don't want you to use Google is based on privacy reasons. Quote from the beginning of the article: > This means they are not only tracking what you search for, they're also tracking which websites you visit, and using all your data for ads that follow you around the internet Apple may be doing the exact same thing as well, so they should not recommend Apple on the same principle. Otherwise it's just preposterous.
- r3bl 9y agoWell, I can guarantee you that Apple doesn't follow you all over the Internet like Google does (edit: and Facebook with its like buttons and commenting platform, probably to lesser extent than Google's analytics and ads). Presumably they're also not making money from your traffic (we can't prove it neither way). I've gone very far in limiting what Google has on me. But if my goal was simply to ditch Google completely, iOS is a completely valid point. So is Vimeo.
- ekianjo 9y agoYou are aware that Apple is selling your search requests to Google right? https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/14/google-paying-apple-3-billion-to-remain-default-search--bernstein.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/14/google-paying-apple-3-billio... It seems that you are hardly going out of the loop by searching for stuff on an iOS device. Google still ends up serving the results and collecting information on you. And by default Safari does not block ads that track you either.
- r3bl 9y agoNope. In that article, it says that Google is paying them to remain the default search provider (exactly what Mozilla used to do with Firefox). Definitely different than Apple "selling search requests". If you switch your search provider to anything non-Google, (presumably) Google is not going to get your search requests.
- grzm 9y ago> You are aware that Apple is selling your search requests to Google right? This way of stating that Google pays to be the default search engine in Safari is inaccurate at best or disingenuous at worst. Phrasing it as you did makes it sound like Apple is hiding the fact that you're using Google and surreptitiously passing on your search information to Google. Sure, one could argue that Apple should use a different engine by default and forgo that $3 billion. That certainly would be something. What's the trade off for them? At this point what major search engine doesn't track? (Yes, DuckDuckGo doesn't, and I use it as my default, but I also think people can reasonably disagree whether it's a major search engine, and I also recognize that the results aren't always as good as Google.) Apple does make it dirt simple to change the default, and doesn't nag you after you've changed it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fortythirteen 9y agoThere is no single good phone option for privacy minded people in the U.S. at the moment, but Apple has definitely shown themselves to be the lesser of two privacy evils. At least Apple stood up to the FBI when they wanted an encryption backdoor.
- ekianjo 9y ago> but Apple has definitely shown themselves to be the lesser of two privacy evils. Only for data physically stored on your phone, but you don't know what they do with your data stored/hosted on their cloud services.
- marian0_ 9y agoIf you care about your privacy you won't upload your stuff to iCloud.
- ekianjo 9y agoi hope you are aware of this kind of problems: https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7455294?start=0&tstart=0 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7455294?start=0&tstart=...
- fortythirteen 9y agoI hope you're not using a potential bug as evidence of malfeasance. There's really no argument here. Google is the world's #1 internet activity-tracking organization. Apple is a hardware company that has data retention policies roughly somewhere around what one would expect for the pervasiveness of it's technology. I don't have to like either, but I'd be a fool to think that we're talking about equal amounts of intrusion. Just what Google could do with the same amount of phone tracking, tied to all the other information it gathers from the multitude of other gathering apparatuses it operates makes an Andriod the less privacy minded option.
- 9y ago
- lrvick 9y agoI think people forget Google didn't 'invent" Android and that it is an open source project based on Linux with many outside contributors. There are open source google-free builds of Android like CopperheadOS which focuses on security and privacy. Many of those security improvements even make it into Google Android builds eventually. We do have some real choices on hardware that happens to ship with Google Android but Apple devices should not be a consideration if one wants to maintain their ability to have choices.
- insertnickname 9y agoI think people forget Google didn't 'invent" Android But they did acquire the company that did.
- AstralStorm 9y agoPlus they reworked it a lot and are reworking it all the time.
- mariusz79 9y agoWe really need some open source OS for smartphones, or rather some smartphones that support anything you throw at them.
- jqs79 9y agoHere's another person looking for an open source OS on mobile phones. Is 1%/30 million users(?) really not enough? All I would like is the ability to make calls, write texts, and perhaps use data occasionally without a multinational corp logging my every packet for eternity/when AI can use it.