3 ms·
I can't help thinking that the captions would make excellent Culture ship names. e.g. ROU Sticky Throttle Valve Edit: In case anyone is wondering about about
by arethuza 9y ago
I can't help thinking that the captions would make excellent Culture ship names.
e.g.
ROU Sticky Throttle Valve
Edit: In case anyone is wondering about about the connection to the Culture, the SpaceX "Autonomous spaceport drone ships" are named after Culture ships:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_spaceport_drone_ship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_spaceport_drone_shi...
Just Read the Instructions
and
Of Course I Still Love You
- sohkamyung 9y agoWas there ever a ship called It's just a scratch ? That's sounds like a good name too.
- arethuza 9y agoApparently not according to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spacecraft_in_the_Culture_series https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spacecraft_in_the_Cult... Rather like 'Look, that's not an "Explosion"' as well... :-) Edit: I'm hoping that the first manned ship on Mars will be "The Ends of Invention".... ;-)
- mschuster91 9y ago> Edit: I'm hoping that the first manned ship on Mars will be "The Ends of Invention".... ;-) Problem with Mars landings is the high turnaround time - while you can see what failed and fix it in a matter of days to weeks on Earth, with Mars you're looking at months to years of having another attempt. Wonder how they'll get it done - practice on Moon first?
- JshWright 9y agoThe Moon is not a super useful analog. It lacks any sort of atmosphere. Mars has just enough atmosphere that you have to deal with it, but not enough of one to be especially useful (parachutes buy you a little, but not much). In fact, some of the best data and tests we have about landing big things on Mars come from SpaceX's first stage booster landings. The burn that the first stage does at the edge of space to slow down is in an environment very similar to that of the Martian atmosphere. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_UFjK_CFKgA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_UFjK_CFKgA
- simonh 9y agoThe Moon isn't a useful analogy precisely because the Martian atmosphere does make a significant difference. Just not enough to allow parachute-only soft landings. I've seen the 'thick enough to be annoying, too thin to be useful' meme before but it doesn't really match reality. For example Pathfinder decelerated from 7.3km/s to 0.4km/s purely using it's aeroshell, before it even deployed the parachutes[0]. Now 0.4km/s is still pretty fast, but a saving of 6.9km/s dV is absolutely enormous. Red Dragon was only possible because, with modifications to the capsule aerodynamics, the Martian atmosphere would brake the capsule enough for it to soft-land on the SuperDracos. There's no way a Dragon could usefuly soft-land on the Moon. It's just way too heavy for it's size. All that thick capsule hull is just dead weight for an airless environment. Given it's high dry mass the rocket equation demands huge amounts of fuel to compensate. The parameters are all wrong for the Moon because it's designed to use atmospheric drag to do most of the work. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_atmospheric_entry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_atmospheric_entry
- rtkwe 9y agoIt's great and useful for smaller probes but as we've sent larger and larger probes the thin Martian atmosphere has been less and less useful. One of the major issues is that the mass keeps going up but the surface area of the heat shields we can reasonably bring along doesn't scale as well. There's some hopes in inflatable technologies though.
- simonh 9y agoThat is a good point. Red Dragon was only feasible by adding an asymmetric sled under the capsule to provide lift, so it could spend significantly longer braking through the atmosphere. Also the ITS video and presentation shows it using it's lifting body design to maximise time up in the atmosphere. At that scale straightforward aeroshells don't cut it, but you can still get a useful effect.
- dtparr 9y agoGood points. I've always taken the spirit of that saying to be more like "thick enough to have to deal with, too thin to be enough". On the moon, you don't have to worry about reentry at all, so no need for a heat shield or any sort of aerodynamic protection, just some way to do a propulsive landing. On earth, you need the heat shield and some aero considerations, but you can land safely with parachutes alone. On mars, you need to deal with reentry but also some sort of propulsive landing system for anything of reasonable size.
- arkh 9y agoThe error we're doing is trying for things to be perfect: sending our best people on our best ships to a possible death. We should do it like old times: get team B, C, D and E and send multiple ships. Even with 75% failure we get one success. And the best are still alive on earth to advise those in space. Same problem with health in space: we send people in peak Earth physical condition. Perfectly adapted to 1G with no radiation. Why don't we try sending people with what are considered physical defect on earth there and see if they're better adapted to space?
- ufmace 9y ago> Why don't we try sending people with what are considered physical defect on earth there and see if they're better adapted to space? That sounds interesting actually. What if we sent up some handicapped people, or people with amputated limbs? Missing legs might be a burden on Earth, but a benefit in space.
- TimMeade 9y agoNice catch. I have read several of the culture books and didn't put that together. Going to read Player of Games next now!
- zbentley 9y agoPlayer of Games is good, but I suspect you'll be disappointed if you're coming from more complex titles like Matter or Use of Weapons. Excession is one of my favorites that's not quite as dense as the rest of his work. Massively off topic, of course.
- Zaak 9y agoTo continue offing the topic: Use of Weapons greatly irritated me. You spend all this time getting to know the guy through flashbacks, then at the end Banks pulls a bait and switch "No it was really the other guy all along!" The book makes no sense with that ending.
- di4na 9y agoQuite the contrary, it does make far more sense with that ending. The whole book is centered around that. It is, by far, my preferred Culture book and the one that apply the best today.