9 ms·
How Not to Land an Orbital Rocket Booster [video]
- KON_Air 9y agoApril 2015; this one looks good enough... then it explodes too.
- JshWright 9y agoIt had a _lot_ of lateral movement at touchdown. A "sticky" valve slowed the engine's response to throttle commands. That led to a feedback loop as it got further and further behind (you can see it gimbaling significantly back and forth).
- arethuza 9y agoI can't help thinking that the captions would make excellent Culture ship names. e.g. ROU Sticky Throttle Valve Edit: In case anyone is wondering about about the connection to the Culture, the SpaceX "Autonomous spaceport drone ships" are named after Culture ships: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_spaceport_drone_ship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_spaceport_drone_shi... Just Read the Instructions and Of Course I Still Love You
- sohkamyung 9y agoWas there ever a ship called It's just a scratch ? That's sounds like a good name too.
- arethuza 9y agoApparently not according to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spacecraft_in_the_Culture_series https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spacecraft_in_the_Cult... Rather like 'Look, that's not an "Explosion"' as well... :-) Edit: I'm hoping that the first manned ship on Mars will be "The Ends of Invention".... ;-)
- mschuster91 9y ago> Edit: I'm hoping that the first manned ship on Mars will be "The Ends of Invention".... ;-) Problem with Mars landings is the high turnaround time - while you can see what failed and fix it in a matter of days to weeks on Earth, with Mars you're looking at months to years of having another attempt. Wonder how they'll get it done - practice on Moon first?
- JshWright 9y agoThe Moon is not a super useful analog. It lacks any sort of atmosphere. Mars has just enough atmosphere that you have to deal with it, but not enough of one to be especially useful (parachutes buy you a little, but not much). In fact, some of the best data and tests we have about landing big things on Mars come from SpaceX's first stage booster landings. The burn that the first stage does at the edge of space to slow down is in an environment very similar to that of the Martian atmosphere. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_UFjK_CFKgA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_UFjK_CFKgA
- simonh 9y agoThe Moon isn't a useful analogy precisely because the Martian atmosphere does make a significant difference. Just not enough to allow parachute-only soft landings. I've seen the 'thick enough to be annoying, too thin to be useful' meme before but it doesn't really match reality. For example Pathfinder decelerated from 7.3km/s to 0.4km/s purely using it's aeroshell, before it even deployed the parachutes[0]. Now 0.4km/s is still pretty fast, but a saving of 6.9km/s dV is absolutely enormous. Red Dragon was only possible because, with modifications to the capsule aerodynamics, the Martian atmosphere would brake the capsule enough for it to soft-land on the SuperDracos. There's no way a Dragon could usefuly soft-land on the Moon. It's just way too heavy for it's size. All that thick capsule hull is just dead weight for an airless environment. Given it's high dry mass the rocket equation demands huge amounts of fuel to compensate. The parameters are all wrong for the Moon because it's designed to use atmospheric drag to do most of the work. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_atmospheric_entry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_atmospheric_entry
- iamrecursion 9y agoI have to appreciate the humour this shows. All in the name of progress, and it certainly made me laugh. SpaceX has somehow managed to turn landing a booster from space into something almost mundane, but it bears remembering the failures that got them there.
- froh42 9y agoYou try and fail. And try and fail. And try and fail. And then one day you have learned enough to try and succeed. Learning how to NOT land it is learning how to land it.
- rlonn 9y agothe road to wisdom - well, it's plain and simple to express: To err and err and err again but less and less and less
- andygates 9y agoAnd if you're smart, rich and lucky, you learn enough before the funding runs out. :)
- phkahler 9y agoThe failures were all very low cost since the rockets actually completed their mission. Once reusability becomes common and lowers the price of launches, failures like those will actually be very expensive for someone else.
- exDM69 9y agoRelatively low cost, yes. But all those recovery efforts, offshore barges, added hardware and software cost actual money that was away from their gross margin from the rocket launches. It was a good move regardless but don't underestimate the amount of time and money spent.
- 9y ago
- fotcorn 9y agoDirect link to video for fullscreen view: https://scontent-frx5-1.cdninstagram.com/t50.2886-16/21732525_713249985525933_1412086930828427264_n.mp4 https://scontent-frx5-1.cdninstagram.com/t50.2886-16/2173252...
- lorenzhs 9y agothat's only the first minute. robin_reala has a full-length youtube version that's also high definition.
- robtaylor 9y ago"I didn't want to be the CEO of SpaceX, I wanted to be a Lumberjack." - Elon Musk
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoSkidders and trucks in the mud vs rockets and barges. Same difference. The toys he gets to play with are just different. Probably way less dick jokes, facial hair and steel toe boots on a SpaceX job-site though.
- JshWright 9y ago> Probably way less dick jokes, facial hair and steel toe boots on a SpaceX job-site though. You don't think these folks are wearing safety tipped shoes and cracking dirty jokes from time to time? https://www.gannett-cdn.com/-mm-/caac49d6e3f44d10409a91a8bb8b6a96db8e03f7/c=206-0-3060-2146&r=x1443&c=1920x1440/local/-/media/2016/05/10/Brevard/Brevard/635984826027372461-SpaceX-at-Port-Canaveral-17.JPG https://www.gannett-cdn.com/-mm-/caac49d6e3f44d10409a91a8bb8...
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThere's an direct relationship between ease of oversight and joke PCness. Twenty dudes in the middle of nowhere turning trees into a piles of logs are gonna be way more fun to hang around with than a team who's supervisor's supervisor could easily drop by. Follow some people who work odd hours on Snapchat/IG. Way more screwing around happens on 3rd shift than 2nd or 1st. IMO the morale boost of allowing people to screw around (relatively speaking) during normal operations offsets the material decrease in productivity because people are more willing to work hard in cases where you need maximum productivity.
- greglindahl 9y agoHuh. I can have fun at work without telling dick jokes.
- robin_reala 9y agoThere’s now a high res version at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvim4rsNHkQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvim4rsNHkQ . Could a mod update the URL for this story?
- dasmoth 9y agoNice compilation, definitely some segments I don't remember seeing before. With those out of the way though... they've attempted 10 landings so far this year and all have been successful. Third flight of a reused booster is planned for early next month. ...and fingers crossed for seeing all three cores from the Falcon Heavy test-flight making successful landings.
- JshWright 9y ago> definitely some segments I don't remember seeing before. I'm bummed there isn't a better video of the March 2016 SES-9 failure (the only shot in this video is the droneship on the horizon). That was the landing that punched a hole in the deck of the droneship.
- agildehaus 9y agoFull video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvim4rsNHkQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvim4rsNHkQ
- dredmorbius 9y agoLanded orbital rocket boosters are all alike; every unlanded orbital rocket boosters is unlanded in its own way.
- smegel 9y agoThey make it look so easy now. In 20 years time we will be saying in amazement "you mean they used to just throw away the boosters after each launch?". Bravo spaceX.
- DanHulton 9y agoI remember first hearing about it and thinking it was science fiction, unable to really be achieved. Glad to be wrong.
- lawlessone 9y agoThey seem very fragile? The one at 0:49 exploded just from tipping over. Perhaps because they're huge i guess.
- marsRoverDev 9y agoThey're probably only built to withstand forces associated with a nominal launch to save on weight; being able to withstand tipping over is unnecessary if you can avoid tipping over in the first place.
- JshWright 9y agoThey are literally thin walled fuel tanks with some rocket engines strapped to the bottom. A soda can dozens of meters tall would be an appropriate analogy.
- bryananderson 9y agoEvery pound of weight you add to the rocket is a pound of payload that you can't put into space.
- JshWright 9y agoIt's not technically 1:1 on the first stage. It varies a bit from launcher to launcher, but it's in the ballpark of 4:1 (you lose a pound of useful payload for every four pounds you add to the first stage). Your point is spot on though. Don't waste mass to account for failure modes that you can just avoid in the first place by landing upright.
- ceejayoz 9y ago> They seem very fragile? They're extremely fragile. In fact, they're stored pressurized because laying on their side would damage them without the pressure keeping the walls rigid.
- mikeash 9y agoMy understanding is that they don't need pressurization while being stored, but do need it to withstand flight loads. This is in contrast to, for example, the older Atlas rockets, which had to be pressurized constantly and would collapse otherwise. Of course I can't find any authoritative source on this, although there are a lot of random internet folks like myself repeating the claim. And I guess I'm throwing one more on the pile here.
- jlebrech 9y agoNow I would like to see them attach 7 boosters together in a hexagonal pattern and get them all to land safely.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoThe Falcon Heavy is basically attaching 3 boosters together in a line. Unfortunately for your vision, the Falcon Heavy boosters separate and land one-by-one as individual boosters. Your idea does make some intuitive sense. While lifting the single booster and even with just one of 9 engines turned down to minimum throttle, when the payload is gone and the tanks are near empty there's an enormous excess of power. The minimum thrust-to-weight ratio is still like 2:1. This means you have to run a "hoverslam" profile which reaches zero velocity precisely at the deck, otherwise you'll take off again. And it means you come in terrifyingly hot and fast, resulting in the explosions in the linked video. With 7 boosters strapped together, you'd think there could be a more appropriate ratio of power and mass, which would enable a more controlled, sedate, hover-and-land profile. If the current 40% throttled down single-engine, single-booster TWR is 2:1, 3 engines would give you a 0.86:1 to 2.14:1 TWR. They could even turn on 3 engines at the outer corners in an equilateral triangle, and use both gimballing and differential thrust to control your descent. It should be easy. You'd just get some struts and select hexagonal symmetry...oh wait, no, that's KSP. In reality, landing 7 boosters at once with a near-unity TWR would be much more expensive in terms of fuel. You want a hoverslam profile that's almost too fast to control, because then you can get your payload higher and faster. Right now, with the single 9-engine booster, they sometimes burn 3 of the 9 engines to land (giving a >6:1 power-to-weight ratio). They do this when they're short on fuel because for every second that they are airborne, they're suffering a 9.8 m/s hit to their delta-V. They want to come down as fast as possible to minimize time in the air.
- jlebrech 9y agomy plan would be to separate the boosters too, you just need them stuck together at launch. or another plan would be to keep them together all the way to mars, and you have a habitation unit above the boosters which is their combined surface area. when you launch the habitation unit you can later land another one next to it the to tile them together.
- zbentley 9y agoMy god, finally something that explodes as easily as all cars do in the movies.
- russellbeattie 9y agoI thought the same thing when that rocket slowly tipped over and still completely self-destructed. I understand rocket fuel is volatile, but wow.
- Narishma 9y agoAre we sure those are not intentionally/automatically triggered explosions?
- Zaak 9y agoThe grasshopper flight that flipped sideways then exploded was blown up by the flight termination system. The rest of them are just pressurized tanks of propellant rupturing in the presence of fire and/or red-hot metal.
- greglindahl 9y agoEverything burns around liquid oxygen.
- monk_e_boy 9y agoHaha, it's a running joke in our family that American cars are made from TNT. Cars on British TV just crash, they don't explode.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoIt reminds me of the collection of failures film in the Redstone and Mercury projects. That said, it also shows how closely managed the release of this video was, after all when you just had a tweet from Elon and no pictures and lots of questions, all you got were crickets. I am glad they finally made it out, if only in partial form, for folks to see. Landing is hard, and there was a lot of things that didn't work. And it is way more open than Blue Origin and their less successful flights.