35 ms·
EU lost up to €5.4B in tax revenues from Google, Facebook: report
- DVassallo 9y agoI wonder how much tax revenue the EU would have lost if Google and Facebook didn't exist.
- ryan-allen 9y agoThat is a very good point. They should be grateful for these multi-nationalistic monopolies. /s
- DVassallo 9y agoJust stating how much taxes are being "avoided" is an imperfect perspective. If, say, it turned out they contributed $100B to the economy, then that $5B wouldn't look that big in that context.
- confounded 9y agoI always struggle with this logic. Is your argument that if 100B EUR in Facebook ads were sold (presumably the way in which Facebook 'contribute'), then this 100B was 'created' by Facebook? I imagine other measures would be proxies for Facebook's profits too (e.g. some portion of engineers' salaries to go private landlords). Isn't this reverse-progressive taxation? If Facebook were outraged at paying taxes enough to shut up shop in Europe, wouldn't that 100B (or something like it) still be kicking around, just in different hands?
- latch 9y agoI get what you're saying, but I think it's fundamentally wrong for two reasons. First, it is "big" when you consider how that money could be used. Cynicism aside about funding wars and filling walls with cash, it could be used for substantive (read: big) social good Secondly, this is an important market. If they don't want to pay taxes, they have the legal option to not do business in Europe. So while you say "5B is small compared to 100B", I say "5B is a small price to pay for the billions they made."
- dangsmum 9y ago"they have a legal option not todo do business in europe" Do you see any way to do that other than to prevent eu businesses buying ads from google? Because i think that might have a few severe unintented consequences for businesses in the eu, and have exactly zero impact on google.
- ryan-allen 9y agoIt'd also open the market to a new competitor when people in the EU (and elsewhere) realised that they can't find local ads on Google.
- latch 9y agoNot sure I understand. You're saying EU business' not allowed to buy ads on Google would have "exactly zero impact on google" ??
- dangsmum 9y agogoogle would still charge the same to display an ad exactly the same number of people will see google ads exactly the same number of people will click on an ad The only thing that would change is companies outside of the eu will burn through their ad budgets faster. plus a whole (not quite so new) industry would emerge outside the eu bypassing the regulations. such as happened in China.
- lovich 9y agoCorporations have a lot of power over countries right now, but does the world you live in ignore everything countries can do to companies who ignore their laws? They can attempt to block everything Google while they build their own local services, ala China. Google is also a US company and while their software might be hard to prevent getting into the EU, they can start leveling sanctions against physical US goods if the US won't do anything to reign Google in. I dont think any of this is likely to happen, but political entities on the scale of the US, China, the EU, etc have options to bend companies to their will
- aweb 9y agoThis isn't the point here though? These companies are doing business in the EU and not playing fair by not paying their share of taxes. This isn't about preventing them from existing, it's about making them contribute what they owe to the EU countries.
- lefstathiou 9y agoI don't want to put words in the parent's mouth but I believe his point is that what is "fair" and what they "owe" are up for debate. Additionally, his question hints at a potentially equally significant and subtle issue: is the effort to capture this increased tax revenue from 4 companies really worth the potential costs on a society to get them? $5bn isnt going to balance Greece's budget. Setting aside the potential arguments defending Google (I have genuinely have no opinion on them or any of the other companies), a comprehensive law that requires every internet company to track every dollar by country and pay proportional taxes on their revenue could, in my opinion, severely cripple innovation in a continent that is finding itself falling behind at a global scale due to a variety of macro-issues. I like to give governments the benefit of the doubt that they won't do something silly like that, but then I look at this net neutrality issue and start to wonder. Bottom line, there does not appear to be a consensus on this issue "morally" (for lack of a better word) which is why we're seeing such diversity of views on HN and globally. Just throwing it out there...
- Oletros 9y agoI wonder how much revenue and profit would have lost Google and Facebook if they didn't exist in the EU
- DVassallo 9y agoHow do they "exist" in the EU? One way to see it is that people from the EU are simply buying services from a US company. It's as if they caught a plane, and paid at a cash register in California. But instead of making the trip, they just sent a check.
- Oletros 9y ago> One way to see it is that people from the EU are simply buying services from a US company I would like how they do businesses, including Amazon and Apple if they leave the EU because the way you see it is totally wrong. Starting with data protection directives and following with dealing with VAT, and EU customers
- seszett 9y ago> How do they "exist" in the EU? They both have headquarters in Dublin.
- Oletros 9y agoAnd physical presence in almost every EU country
- DVassallo 9y agoSo if they didn't have a physical presence in the EU, then it would have been fine not to tax them?
- DannyBee 9y agoWhich i'm sure they would happily burn to the ground if it meant they weren't taxed there. I don't think you want to go with the argument of physical presence. It rarely works well with any multinational.
- rockinghigh 9y agoFacebook most likely reduces the productivity of citizens.
- kuschku 9y agoNo company just adds 100% of its value. Facebook isn’t anything new – maybe it adds 10% more value than MySpace would have had if Facebook didn’t exist in the EU. Maybe it adds 20% more value than the VZ Networks would have added. You can’t just look at the entire value these companies provide, because local providers existed before Facebook and Google replaced them. Yes, Google and Facebook are overally more efficient, but only by a small amount.
- qxmat 9y agoLarge tech companies employ hollywood accounting techniques to continually reinvest surplus revenue. In doing so they rarely post any significant profit, depriving the taxmax of corporation tax. This 'reinvestment' is used to compete and drive profitable competitors out of business. This is an unfair practice. The result - no profitable companies, smaller taxable base and nothing for the taxman to collect. The bigger the juggernaut, the more influence they have on the taxman ("but we're contributing to pay/income/property taxes - surely you don't want us to relocate abroad"). Large multinationals use their corrupting influence to strike sweetheart deals and use these deal-made tax savings to abuse the market even more.
- mjevans 9y agoIt doesn't just have to be tech companies, but the interesting thing is the abuse of 'intellectual property' (a thing which governments literally imagined in to existence) being used to transfer around wealth through agreements that, without it, wouldn't hold any water.
- themihai 9y agoWell, I guess Myspace and Yahoo would still be a thing...or new players would take their palce...so don't worry about that.
- dangsmum 9y agoWhat gives the EU the right to think they can tax our networks? Do they not realise that trying to do so will just drive all digital revenue to places that don't?
- gaius 9y agoThere's no such thing as "digital revenue" - all this money comes from the real economy.
- dangsmum 9y agothats what the bitcoin detractors said, didnt work out to well for them did it? and anyway, even if you limit it to "real economy" (if anything in cyberspace can really be counted as real, which is highly suspect) it comes from ad revenue. all taxing eu ad revenue in cyberspace will do is ensure eu companies cant competitively show their ads in cyberspace, doing so will lose the eu a lot more than just "tax".
- gaius 9y agoThis resulted in estimated revenue losses for EU states, other than Ireland, of between 51 and 54 billion euros between 2013 and 2015 Typo in the headline? Seems to be off by a factor of 10.
- tyrw 9y agoIs the EU tax based on revenue instead of profit? Or is basing it on revenue in this instance just supposed to make the "percentage paid" smaller to make FB and Google look worse?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- MarkCole 9y agoI believe the article is just poorly worded in that regard. > "It says that Google pays taxes worth up to 9 percent of its revenues outside the EU" They're simply asserting that Google currently pays 9% of its revenue in taxes outside of the EU. I don't believe they are calculating their lost tax revenue that way. To answer your question in the EU corporate tax is yes based on profit. Your revenue minus your expenses.
- newen 9y agoNot really. The idea is that they are hiding their profits, and so their profits are not being taxed. But the actual profit (as a percentage of the revenue) that they are hiding is expected to be similar inside and outside of the EU.
- friendzis 9y agoDirectly mentioned in the article: “Facebook’s taxes as a share of their revenues recorded outside the EU is between 28 percent and 34 percent, whereas in the EU this is a remarkably low ratio of 0.03 percent to 0.10 percent,” the report adds. Profit numbers are very susceptible to accounting gymnastics. EBITDA and revenue, on the other hand, are more difficult to manipulate. If you make assumption that companies in the same domain have similar operations, then profit margin, and by extension taxes paid on reported profits, should be similar. Based on this assumption, one can say that it is worth looking into when companies in the same domain have significantly different reported profit margins or reported profit margins differ significantly based on location. Tax to revenue ratios in this case differing by two orders of magnitude raise some eyebrows.
- 9y ago
- marcell 9y agoStrategically, I wonder Google/FB/etc. would do better to pay more taxes. The recent GDPR is a total disaster for them. Maybe it could have been avoided if they paid more taxes, and were on friendlier terms with the EU.
- TAForObvReasons 9y agoIt's the same problem with any industry where the laws haven't caught up yet: acting in good faith helps when the laws start to catch up, and being too aggressive/exploitative only ensures the new laws will close the existing loopholes and yet-to-be-envisioned ones
- confounded 9y agoI'm afraid they would rather minimize their tax bill and maximize their lobbying bill.
- peoplewindow 9y agoThey can't be on friendly terms with the EU because this issue is being driven by internal EU politics and not really anything specific to tech. The poster above has it right. The EU's goal is to become a new country that eliminates the existing countries. To do that it must have either have its own tax base, or control the member states tax. It is working on both of those simultaneously, trying to control Ireland's tax policies, and also trying to treat fines on tech firms for vague anti-trust "violations" as a kind of taxation. Note that the EU Commission does not have to win in court to claim billion dollar fines, they can simply declare a fine by fiat, thus giving them a massive incentive to abuse their powers.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- SilentCrossing 9y agoSo I want to implement Common Consolidated Corporate Tax Base CCCTB across Europe, which means I want to have the power to determine the rules for the whole EU. I then create a report projecting that we could increase our tax revenue if we pass the law to give me more power. I have some thoughts. 1) The projected windfall from this CCCTB will not materialize... if we take history as a indicator. When ever does companies or people not react to increased taxes? 2) Losing the ability to attract international companies will hurt countries / cities that are lower on the marketability scale. Would the 'Celtic Tiger' miracle have happened if they did not have the sovereignty to attract international companies with lower taxes. That is doubtful at best. 3) Competition, including taxes, is great for Europeans. If we study history we see that competition is one of the components that resulted in the dominance of the west. (see Civilization: Is the West History?) 4) The biggest reason Brussels is doing this is not to have to ask each country for money anymore. These negotiations have become more tough for Brussels, since the countries are pushing back on exorbitant spending by Brussels.
- mc32 9y agoWhy not for the whole world and get rid of tax havens for corps and for wealthy indivs as well? This would put pressure and incentives on govt's to be fairer about taxes in multiple ways. We've got corps who won't repatriate money cuz profits overseas...[apple and indivs with overseas shell cos, etc.]
- SilentCrossing 9y agoThe article was about giving tax creation power to Brussels and removing that power from the EU countries. This would not result in a fairer tax, but a tax that you have voice in changing. Brussel bureaucrats are not voted into office by the people and can therefore also not be removed from office by the people. I agree that governments should strife for a fairer tax and a good start would be a simpler tax. There I agree that unnecessary complexity have created loopholes. I however do think that the European Union should set the example and start paying taxes like normal citizens in their respective countries. The European Patent Offices in Europe do not pay any taxes in the countries they are situated. They have their own internal low tax system. Talk about writing your own rules for avoiding taxes. Just to touch on the issue of USA companies not repatriating money back to the USA. This is a problem with the USA tax code. The Netherlands for example do not have this issue, since they have double tax treaties with various countries and when they do not have a treaty the participation exemptions kicks in. The participation exemption says that you will not be taxed again in the Netherlands if you own >= 5% of a foreign company when a dividend is payed from the daughter company to parent companies. The logic of the dutch is that foreign dividends have been taxes and is therefore exempt.
- seanieb 9y ago"This resulted in estimated revenue losses for EU states, other than Ireland" What does this mean? Ireland is in the EU. It's like complaining France or Germany don't share their tax revenue proportionally with the rest of the EU states. Ireland and other EU states have sovereignty over their own tax laws. If you change that you will basically change what the EU is.
- Heliosmaster 9y agoWhich is what the point of the article is about. What if the EU was more harmonized, especially at a fiscal level?
- markvdb 9y agoIreland has sovereignty over its tax law to a certain extent. For VAT for example there is an EU minimum standard rate of 15% (with an option for a reduced rate). One of the biggest loopholes is _finally_ expiring in 2020: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement . Something else Ireland is limited in is custom tax deals/rulings with individual companies. As an EU member state, one can not just decide to apply an individual tax base or tax rate reduction without basing this in reality, hence https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/31/technology/apple-tax-eu-ireland.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/31/technology/apple-tax-eu-i... .
- themihai 9y agoIreland made some kind of special arrangements. For example Apple paid the full tax for products sold in Ireland but only aprox 1% or even less for the products sold in the rest of EU. It's like saying "come to Ireland" and pay no tax to the rest of EU. Ireland is happy because they cash in the tax for the products sold in Ireland plus an extra for the products sold in the rest of EU. If you ask me tax should be paid where the profit is generated.
- Neracked 9y agoIreland is basically selling multinational corporations the right to avoid paying their taxes to other European countries in which they have significant activity.
- DannyBee 9y ago"This resulted in estimated revenue losses for EU states, other than Ireland, of between 51 and 54 billion euros between 2013 and 2015, the report concluded." So if i understand this right, this is basically: the EU didn't really lose anything, since ireland is in the EU, but the other states would have gotten more in total if they weren't allowed to do this? My other understanding is that the tax laws of all the EU countries are not controlled by the EU, but by the individual countries? If so, this sounds like it would be like saying "US states lose billions in tax revenue from Google because they locate in delaware" Is that a reasonable conversion for a US'ian?
- sddfd 9y agoNot really. Ireland has some deals going with several digital multinationals. The guardian writes: "Google pays €47m in tax in Ireland on €22bn sales revenue" https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/nov/04/google-pays-47m-euros-tax-ireland-22bn-euros-revenue https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/nov/04/google-pays...
- gaius 9y agoIreland is only able to charge such low corporation tax due to the generous subsidies it receives from the EU too.
- anonymousDan 9y agoEh? Think you need to get your facts straight: https://amp.independent.ie/business/irish/ireland-contributes-more-money-than-it-gets-to-eu-for-first-time-34815450.html https://amp.independent.ie/business/irish/ireland-contribute...
- endless1234 9y agoHm? "For the first time since it joined the bloc in 1973" "Since 1973, Ireland has received over €50bn."
- petre 9y agoThe title says EUR 5.4B, the text of the article states "between 51 and 54 billion euros". How is this accurate reporting on Reuters' part?
- cJ0th 9y agoMaybe something got lost in translation. In Germany (and maybe it's similar in other EU countries), "Billion" = 10^12 and "Milliarde" = 10^9. In English, otoh, billion = 10^9. see, for instance: https://www.dict.cc/?s=billion&=DEEN&= https://www.dict.cc/?s=billion&=DEEN&=
- Heliosmaster 9y agoAlso not to forget is that sometimes companies make "deals" with countries, to pay less taxes than what was owed in the first place: http://www.reuters.com/article/us-italy-apple-tax/apple-to-pay-italy-318-million-euros-sign-tax-deal-source-idUSKBN0UD13K20151230 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-italy-apple-tax/apple-to-p...
- staticelf 9y agoI really hope a new tax bill comes through, I am tired of US companies (and others) that can simply avoid paying tax while small shops pay a lot of taxes in the EU. They use our well developed infrastructure for their own benefit and does not pay anything back. I hope they get a fat bill.
- l5870uoo9y 9y agoThe underlying problem is that companies take advantage of "globalization". Companies can legally move not only their production abroad but also the profit. So companies naturally — with the blessing of American business inteligensia — avoid taxes. I think national control of the economy is eminent and is the only way forward if you want to realize and spread some of the tremendous opportunities and benefits that automatization and digitalization brings us.
- microcolonel 9y agoFundamentally the "problem" lies in the fact that the nominal tax rate they can expect to pay in the United States is the highest among all the developed nations. Ireland is prudent and wise enough to be the better home for their revenues. Globalization means that nations, provinces, and municipalities compete for the patronage of businesses. If you want a global economy, but you also want to be the legal home of Google and Microsoft, you will need to compete globally to offer better ROI: both in the cost of doing business, and in the proportion of the return which they get to keep. This is also why we keep piling on exceptions and deductions in order to stop the bleeding and keep at least some major firms from migrating all of their capital out of the country.
- heavenlyblue 9y agoFundamently the problem lies in the fact that civilised countries forget how much more social security a corporation gets from operating a business in there: no hostile takeovers, police coming in time, medical insurance for their employees, functional legal systems. Take all of this away and a corporation is going to be killed instantly (you're a victim of fraud on a massive scale? you haven't payed your taxes this year, so no retribution for you). So no, I don't think the fundamental issue is just the ROI.
- whb07 9y agoI wonder what would happen if G/F just upped and "left" the EU? Ensuring to close every physical location as they did so. I wonder how much of a bind the politicians would be trying to remain in power as they would be in the position of trying to add Google and Facebook to the ban list or just continuing like normal except with less tax revenue. Does anyone here really believe that any EU bureaucrat would ban Facebook and Google? Enforce a massive ban like China or some dictatorship? I think it's one thing to never have had. It's another to have had and then have it taken away. The latter is infinitely more painful.
- Thiez 9y agoDo you honestly think that without US companies, there will be no search engines and social networks? Here in the Netherlands we had Hyves[1] before we had Facebook, which was pretty big. If, for whatever reason, Facebook were to vanish tomorrow from the EU tomorrow, I have little doubt that we'd all be on a different social network by Christmas. Of course there would be a lot of complaining during the first two weeks. I would miss Google more than I would Facebook, but perhaps an influx of 500 million new users would give competing search engines the income to improve their results to equal those of Google (perhaps they're already of comparable quality and I just haven't noticed). Google and Facebook are making a lot of money in the EU, and leaving the EU because they have to pay more taxes would be like cutting off the nose to spite the face. It just wouldn't make financial sense, and shareholders would (understandably) be furious. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyves
- whb07 9y agoI didn't say they would truly close their doors to EU business. Very much the same way they operate in most of the world, that they should apply that to the EU. Google/Facebook don't have offices in over 100+ countries and yet they clearly serve those consumers from those countries just fine. Take for example my country of Ecuador. I'd find it hard to believe that any tech company is paying taxes in Ecuador and yet their citizens reap vast uses and benefits from Google/Facebook. I'm guessing this applies to 99% of other countries as well. I'm of a libertarian skew, so most taxes are essentially theft to keep the fat bureaucracy happy. In the case of the EU it's clear extortion.
- elgenie 9y agoTaxing multinational corps is pretty difficult. Let's say a parent company UsTech, which makes money from ads on a ubiquitous digital platform, has an Irish subsidiary UsTechDublin,LLC and a German subsidiary UsTechBerlin,GMBH. UsTechBerlin hosts a bunch of very well paid engineers who work on app performance and backend infrastructure efficiency; UsTechDublin hosts a bunch of low paid customer service reps that provide support to end users. Both offices clearly provide something of value that helps the parent company UsTech make money, but nobody has paid a (euro)cent to purchase ads from either the Irish or German offices while those offices have paid a bunch of money in salary and benefits. So, how much should they owe the tax man in each country? That's up to UsTech. The "revenue" "earned" by UsTechDublin is an accounting-only transfer from UsTech for providing customer service. The "revenue" "earned" by UsTechBerlin is an accounting-only transfer from UsTech for performance improvements and infrastructure designs. If corporate tax rates in Germany and Ireland are higher than those in the US and UsTech accountants aren't total morons, the transfer payment to each subsidiary will be exactly enough to ensure that revenue matches expenses and there's no profit to be taxed on the books of either UsTechDublin or UsTechBerlin. If, on the other hand, the corporate tax rate in Ireland is lower than in the US and the corporate tax rate in Germany is higher then magically services of the customer service reps of UsTechDublin may be "sold" to UsTech at usurious rates while those of the software engineers of UsTechBerlin are "sold" for a pittance. The "lost" tax revenue being claimed here is essentially saying that multinationals chose their transfer payments in such a way as to not have their profits appear in high-tax EU nations. Well … duh. The problem is that it's hard to envision a governmental bureaucracy capable of challenging and very accurately assessing the true rates on intra-subsidiary transfers without it being breathtakingly large in scope and stifling to the functioning of the economy in question. Current rules for it [1] leave plenty of wiggle room. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_pricing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_pricing
- alkonaut 9y agoWhat you are describing is exactly the issue with the current system, correct? That is, taxation based on physical presence only, and the arbitrary ways corporationsn can do intra-subsidiary transfers. A tax for megacorps based on revenue seems a lot simpler.
- doe88 9y agoSeems fair to me you should pay in any country proportionally as much as you generate revenues from that country.
- MarkMc 9y agoThe report "says that Google pays taxes worth up to 9 percent of its revenues outside the EU, but this ratio goes down to no more than 0.82 percent inside the EU". Does anyone know what percent of US revenue Google pays in US taxes? I'm pretty sure it's not 9%
- VeronicaJJ123 9y agoEU lost ? or the governments lost ? It is a big difference actually.
- addHocker 9y agoThats what china tought us all about mega-corps, they may try to outrun and subvert all laws, but at the end, as long as you controll acess to the citizens, you can make them dance.
- wetpaws 9y agoIs it just me or trans-national corporations will eventually erode our concept of states and borders?