3 ms·
There seem to be two sort of unrelated criticisms here. One's a preference for GUI (or at least full-screen console-mode) interfaces over CLIs, and generally fo
by _delirium 16y ago
There seem to be two sort of unrelated criticisms here. One's a preference for GUI (or at least full-screen console-mode) interfaces over CLIs, and generally for fewer config files and command-line options. The other is a dislike of chaining piped commands, and a suggestion that integrated scripting languages like Perl are the replacement. But those seem like two pretty wildly different directions to go in. And there doesn't seem to be any argument for either of the points, just personal preference ("I don't like the Unix aesthetic, and you shouldn't either").
The more specific examples are pretty weird, also. Just about every Unix comes with a full-screen text file viewer ('nano' is a decent one). If you don't like bash, you can use a different shell; I mean, he was willing to use a third-party shell on Windows, why not on Unix? One option: http://fishshell.org/ http://fishshell.org/
- commandar 16y agoThis may be totally unfair to author, but the impression I got was that he was using *nix without really understanding it.
- lucifer 16y agoThe essay was about programming aesthetics. (Related: http://www.jwz.org/doc/worse-is-better.html http://www.jwz.org/doc/worse-is-better.html) My read of it was that systems 'like' Unix are in a cooperative relationship with their end-users, and are not the 'servant'. This burden on the user is rewarded with the 3 cited characteristics. He further framed this relationship in terms of "dated" main frame style programming and concerns -- scarce computational resources and subsequent minimalist (some would say cryptic) approach to defining the API for the OS. Certainly you can put a pretty GUI on top of Unix: http://artbinaire.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/iphone-steve-jobs.jpg http://artbinaire.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/iphone... (Hello?:) That's not the point. The point is that that pretty shiny GUI is not as stable as the underlying OS. But the reward here is that the "system" is in a master-servant relationship. ("man pages" ...)