4 ms·
Only if one thinks the physicalist explanations so far are satisfactory. I'm guessing the meaningless philosophical hand-wavers find it less than satisfactory.
by goatlover 9y ago
Only if one thinks the physicalist explanations so far are satisfactory. I'm guessing the meaningless philosophical hand-wavers find it less than satisfactory. They might even say the same thing about the physicalist explanations.
- naasking 9y agoPhysicalists can't yet explain everything because our knowledge is incomplete. We all know this. Every thought experiment purporting to invalidate physicalism is also either fatally flawed, or simply points to a knowledge gap that we haven't yet explored. None of the above justifies declaring physicalism "insufficient" or "unsatisfactory". People adopt anti-physicalist philosophies because they don't like the idea of being an automaton, not because the arguments against it are sound.
- danielam 9y agoI never said anything about physicalism or that consciousness requires anything immaterial. I suggest you acquaint yourself with the subject matter. You've only offered us a few uninformed claims and bizarre reactions.
- naasking 9y agoI'm quite well acquainted with the subject matter, thanks. I frankly don't see how your original comment could possibly be interpreted other than as an anti-physicalist position.