4 ms·
> I wish I knew how to spark a discussion about hypotheses that are physical, but don't reduce to information processing You can't. Information is physical. Ma
by naasking 9y ago
> I wish I knew how to spark a discussion about hypotheses that are physical, but don't reduce to information processing
You can't. Information is physical. Matter irreducibly contains information: https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=3327 https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=3327
What you need to do is get over the prejudice that information processing is undesirable as an explanation for consciousness.
- psyc 9y agoI simply don't have a strong reason at this point to believe it is sufficient. That everything is information is, IMO a tautology, and citing it as an explanation is like citing matter and/or energy as an explanation. But is it inherently conscious, or is there a minimum necessary condition in terms of arrangement, data flow, or other physical evolution of a localized system?
- naasking 9y agoAll good questions, but do you really have strong reasons for thinking consciousness is not physical? There seems little need to posit consciousness as some irreducible property of matter, except for those who are mysteriously uncomfortable with the idea of being purely physical beings. Most arguments against physicalism are smoke and mirrors. As for specifically what physical process produces consciousness, it's an open question that's being studied. We're currently like Ada Lovelace studying a web browser and marvelling at what it does, having little idea how it actually works, yet we're mostly convinced it's not magic. I think you'd be more forgiving if Miss Lovelace took some time trying to reverse engineer the operation of a computer and it's program. Personally, I think [1] is a great starting point on this journey. The problem of apparent subjectivity was a huge stumbling block, and I think that paper is a great stab at it. [1] http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00500/full http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00...
- monktastic1 9y agoNice to see you again, naasking :) It doesn't require any "mysterious discomfort." Believing in the existence of a physical reality may seem like a totally reasonable extrapolation to make from our experiences, but it's not the only one.
- naasking 9y agoNot the only one, simply the most plausible one! I can't answer the ultimate skeptic except to say that not only do skeptical arguments against knowledge depend on that very same knowledge, and so undermine themselves, but even if that were not so, abstract musings will never be more plausible than the concrete reality staring you in the face.
- monktastic1 9y agoThat's fair, but the skeptical argument isn't my main concern. The point is that subjective phenomena are the most basic facts of my existence, so it's not even meaningful for me to explain (or worse, deny) them with respect to (in favor of) things I extrapolated from them. I think last time you didn't agree that subjective phenomena were the most immediate facts of my experience. If that's still the case, perhaps I can try to be more precise.
- naasking 9y agoIn principle, no set of third party objective facts can capture first person subjective facts. This is part of the hard problem. The question is whether human subjectivity actually is true first person, irreducible subjectivity, or just an illusion of it. Consider the analogy to sight: seeing is believing right? And yet, at some point you'll see an optical illusion whose logical properties are simply inconsistent with other properties you've seen. Like how water appears to break pencils [1]. So how do you reconcile this? Clearly seeing can't always entail believing. Enter science. As I linked elsewhere in this thread, science can explain fake subjectivity quite well. So your choice would seem to be throwing away our best tool for objective knowledge just to preserve some special property of human minds that ultimately makes no real difference. [1] http://www.physicsclassroom.com/mmedia/optics/bp.cfm http://www.physicsclassroom.com/mmedia/optics/bp.cfm
- psyc 9y agoAs I wrote above, I am only interested in hypotheses that are physical. Perhaps you mean less fundamental than a field? I'm open to that. This paper is very interesting, thank you. I read it as proposing a self-referential, possibly recursive, stack of attention processes and models. Sounds like Hofstadter's ideas.
- goatlover 9y agoBut what reason is there to suppose that information processing is any better at explaining consciousness than normal physics or neuroscience, for that matter? The hard problem of concrete subjectivity remains no matter which objective, abstract explanation you prefer.
- naasking 9y agoBecause the language of physics and neuroscience is mathematics aka information processing.
- goatlover 9y agoThat might be so. It's intriguing. But that still doesn't close the gap on explaining consciousness.
- naasking 9y agoThere are many gaps in our scientific knowledge, yet for nearly every such gap except consciousness, we are quite certain that science will close those gaps. Why is that?
- goatlover 9y agoThe argument is that consciousness is subjectively experienced, while science is an objective explanation. There's a very fundamental split regarding objectivity and subjectivity. And the nature of what it means to explain something. As for closing gaps, do we really expect science to be able to explain everything in terms of some fundamental theory, from quarks to societies? Or maybe in terms of emerging complexity going from chemistry all the way up to social organization?
- naasking 9y ago> The argument is that consciousness is subjectively experienced, while science is an objective explanation. Certainly consciousness appears to be subjective experience. That doesn't make it so. See: http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00500/full http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00... > As for closing gaps, do we really expect science to be able to explain everything in terms of some fundamental theory, from quarks to societies? That certainly seems to be the trend. Every step forward in some field sheds light on other fields, and cross-disciplinary work is becoming ever more relevant.