3 ms·
Why is anyone surprised these big tech companies become monopolies? They are explicitly granted that power through patents. Amazon and Google have been grante
by djyaz1200 9y ago
Why is anyone surprised these big tech companies become monopolies? They are explicitly granted that power through patents. Amazon and Google have been granted long monopolies by key patents they hold for things like one click buying and bidding on search results respectively. 17 years is too long for a patent in tech IMO. Something more like 6/7 years seems more appropriate. The patent office (run until recently by a Google alum) basically stopped issuing new meaningful software patents. The judicial system makes it very expensive to enforce patents and the media has labeled rights holders trolls (in fairness some are bad actors). The aggregate of these forces... making patents last too long, making them expensive/difficult to enforce and rarely issuing defensible/valuable new IP is DRAMATICALLY favoring the interests of big tech giants. Therefore, a key step in limiting monopoly power is thoughtful patent reform. Let small startups secure IP faster/easier and defend it without labeling them trolls. Make patents expire faster so companies can have a head start but not own a market for nearly a generation. Those changes would provide a steady stream of new challengers the opportunity regularly try to come "kill the kings". That's how to limit the otherwise inevitable aggregation of money/power that comes with entrenched/unchallenged success.
- talmand 9y agoTo me it's not the length of the patents, but the granting of patents that shouldn't have been done in the first place. Like the countless patents that follow the "take Patent A and add 'with computer' on it to create Patent B" formula.
- djyaz1200 9y agoIt's not binary. There are some questionable patents out there for sure, but that doesn't mean that innovators shouldn't be able to get reasonable patents to incentivize risk taking. It's a complicated problem.
- talmand 9y agoI see a difference between reasonable and obvious.
- blackrock 9y agoPull down to refresh. Granted to Twitter. Slide to unlock. Granted to Apple, then invalidated. Rounded rectangles. Granted to Apple. (Freeway signs had this for decades.) Jiggle mode to move or delete apps. Granted to Apple. These are just a few of the crazy software UI patents that were granted. Can anyone think of any more?