3 ms·
Yes, if the government were to mandate that Cloudflare refuse service to neo-Nazi websites, that would be a violation of the First Amendment. But it is not ille
by danso 9y ago
Yes, if the government were to mandate that Cloudflare refuse service to neo-Nazi websites, that would be a violation of the First Amendment. But it is not illegal for Cloudflare itself to refuse service based on content.
- rtpg 9y agoI think the GP was saying it would be unconstitutional to _force_ Cloudflare to serve neo-Nazis. "We needed a constitutional ammendment for many protected classes, because otherwise there's issues with other rights" is the idea here perhaps?
- thehardsphere 9y agoIt would be unconstitutional, though a version this question is going before the Supreme Court right now in that case involving Christian bakers and gay wedding cakes. I think the baker's lawyers are basing their argument on that sort of reasoning. I haven't followed the case closely enough to tell if that premise itself is actually in question, or if it's whether that premise is overridden by some other (e.g. regarding anti-discrimination laws).
- Zuider 9y agoThe baker's lawyers are arguing that a customized cake is a form of personal artistic expression, and that punishing a business for refusing to provide such an item amounts to compelled speech.