4 ms·
Why do you believe that particular creation story instead of one of the hundreds of other creation stories [1] from around the world? [1] https://en.wikipedia.
by tzs 9y ago
Why do you believe that particular creation story instead of one of the hundreds of other creation stories [1] from around the world?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_creation_myths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_creation_myths
- tptacek 9y agoI know you don't mean it to be, but the way you've worded that question makes it somewhat rude and very unlikely to generate the response you're hoping for.
- humanrebar 9y agoI have thicker skin than that, but not everyone does. Thanks!
- tzs 9y agoIs that because I included the Wikipedia link, and Wikipedia calls them all myths?
- tptacek 9y agoThere's that, and there's the fact that people of mainstream faiths tend to resent their beliefs being compared to primitive animism, and there's the fact that those comparisons are also an Internet atheist activist trope. But more generally it's a little weird asking someone outright why they belong to a particular religion. It's not something you're meant to litigate. We rightly feel irritated when fundamentalist Christians proselytize to strangers; this is another instance of the same thing.
- tzs 9y ago> But more generally it's a little weird asking someone outright why they belong to a particular religion. Even in a thread whose whole point is a discussion of religious belief and why people are religious? > We rightly feel irritated when fundamentalist Christians proselytize to strangers; this is another instance of the same thing. When people proselytize for their religion they are implicitly if not explicitly telling you that your current beliefs in that area are wrong and that theirs are right. I agree that is irritating. I don't think that asking someone why they believe their religion is the same thing.
- tptacek 9y agoI'm comfortable disagreeing on these issues (especially since they're subtle) if you recognize the concerns I mentioned that didn't make your reply. :)
- tzs 9y agoSure. I wasn't trying to compare to animism. I included the Wikipedia link because I said that there were hundreds of creation stories and thought that if I didn't give some link to a bunch of them someone might get testy over the number. (I'm kind of surprised that hasn't happened anyway, as the Wikipedia list only has 40 or so).
- tptacek 9y agoIt's interesting to consider how many things you believe at your core that you can't easily connect back to rationalism. Most western cultural values are ahistorical and disconnected from any modern notion of biological imperative.
- humanrebar 9y agoWhy believe they're all false just because there are many? Any atheist creation story is just one more in the list. But, to narrow things down, the Genesis account is dislike most of those in that: 1. It's ex nihilo, so it doesn't leave loose ends out there like, "Yeah, but where did the giant turtle come from?" I'll point out that atheist philosophy has this problem at least with respect to matter and energy. 2. It's monotheistic, so complications about where the many gods come from, what rules they have to follow, and how they die are moot. 3. It doesn't make clearly-not-true claims about the nature of reality (great beasts, corpses of giants, etc.). I know people disagree on this point, but I think most people who reject the Genesis account haven't fully deliberated on this question. Now, I didn't start at genesis and work my way through the Bible to my current beliefs. I don't find that people generally convert to Abrahamic religions that way. But I do find that people mistakenly think there's a contradiction between science (evolution, astronomy) and the Genesis story, which is why I said something.
- tzs 9y ago> Why believe they're all false just because there are many? Any atheist creation story is just one more in the list. I didn't say or imply that they are all false. You are reading more, I think, into my question than was there.
- humanrebar 9y agoDidn't mean to single you out. Apologies. I was trying to point out (for the lurkers if not you) that atheism doesn't get a free pass just because there are all sorts of creation stories to consider. A materialist story is a story nonetheless.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> It's ex nihilo, No, it's not. > so it doesn't leave loose ends out there like, "Yeah, but where did the giant turtle come from?" How is “Yeah, but where did God come from?” not a loose ends almost exactly like that? > It's monotheistic, so complications about where the many gods come from, what rules they have to follow, and how they die are moot. It has a single creator (like many polytheistic creation myths), and multiple supernatural entities raising the same type of questions (even if you literally interpret the serpent as just a really smart snake with an unexplained defiant streak, by the end of Gen 3 you’ve got the cherub with the flaming sword.) That the supernatural entities besides the creator in the Judeo-Christian tradition are called something other than gods doesn't actually eliminate any of the issues they raise.