4 ms·
Does this difference in job preference extend to times and places where different genders dominate some fields? For example, teaching used to be a predominantly
by mikeash 9y ago
Does this difference in job preference extend to times and places where different genders dominate some fields? For example, teaching used to be a predominantly male job in the US until the late 19th century. For a less extreme example, there used to be (proportionally) many more women in computing just a few decades ago than there are now.
I'm highly suspicious of any claim that biology affects typically gendered jobs, whether because of suitability or just because of preference, because it seems like gender roles in employment ought to be a lot more consistent if that were true.
- belorn 9y agoHistorical aspects carries with them the two world wars and men-only military drafts, where young men were forcibly sent to the front line while young women volunteered/took jobs to help the war effort through computing. The history of computing is soaked in historical context.
- mikeash 9y agoEverything is soaked in historical context, including how things are today. If what we see now is biological, then that implies we've somehow just arrived at a point where we eliminated external factors, which doesn't make sense to me. And I don't buy this explanation about the war. Women were significantly more present in computing as late as the 1980s. For example, the percentage of women majoring in computer science was over 35% in 1985, versus under 20% today.
- belorn 9y agoDuring the second world war, it was way above 35%. Gender segregation isn't some instant state that as soon the war ends switches from 100% women to 100% men. Nothing is that black and white. Effects from wars are neither eternal nor instant. In economy people are still saying that we are seeing ripples from the world war 2, but at some point those ripple effects will be too small to be relevant. It is relevant to explain the economy during the 1960, somewhat for 1980, but less so for 2017. To claim that a profession born out of war isn't effect by war politics seems odd.
- mikeash 9y agoLike I said, everything is affected by historical context. What's odd is to pretend that the present situation is somehow an exception. And the defense that the larger number of women in CS in the 80s was a long effect from the war still doesn't make sense, given that the number had been going up for quite some time at that point.
- belorn 9y agoIf you want to look at a historical perspective when there were more women that men in the computing industry, you got to go back much further than the 80s and much closer to the 50s. There was one interesting thing happening 1975 however. The US stopped sending millions of young men away from the work force and fight in Vietnam, often to never return. After 1975 the school system also had a massive intake of male students, both old and new. Young men was not sent to die, and old men who survived the forced military draft was given an opportunity to study. Maybe a coincident, but that match quite well the census data. When there was wars, women had a upwards trend in the computing industry. When there was peace there is a slight delay for education to catch up and then more men enters the work force.
- mikeash 9y agoSure, women were a minority in the field in 1985, but they were a much larger minority than they are today. I don't see how the end of US involvement in the Vietnam War would explain the percentage of female CS majors peaking a decade later. Why are you so insistent that there must be some historical aspect behind the numbers of the past, but not the numbers of the present? What makes you think that the way things are today is the "natural" state of things, when it was never the case before?
- JamesBarney 9y agoWe can't give the test to people in the 19th century without a time machine. But we can do one better. We can give the test to people who are genetically male but who look like and are raised as female. Individuals with congenital adrenal hyperplasia look exactly like women and were raised as women.(think Jamie Lee Curtis) but they are genetically male. And they found that these individuals had significantly more male patterned likes and dislikes. This is evidence that at least half of the preference is biological.
- mikeash 9y agoBut is what's biological a preference for specific types of jobs, or is it a preference for what society considers "male" jobs? I don't see how this test could distinguish the two.
- JamesBarney 9y agoIs your alternative hypothesis that women are biologically programmed to conform to society's ideas about what a woman should do, with prenatal testosterone reducing that conformity impulse?
- mikeash 9y agoEssentially yes. Maybe women are typically drawn to stereotypically female roles, and men to stereotypically male roles, and having more male-like hormones causes women to be drawn to stereotypically male roles instead. How does the hypothesis that women are biologically drawn to certain types of jobs, regardless of stereotyped roles, explain the fact that this stuff constantly changes?