3 ms·
Wait, 5-10 billion USD for something that would prevent the complete collapse of civilization and Congress won't pony up the money?
by macintux 9y ago
Wait, 5-10 billion USD for something that would prevent the complete collapse of civilization and Congress won't pony up the money?
- bbctol 9y agoUnless voters make it a priority, Congress won't do a damn thing. EDIT: Which is how democracy should work!
- talmand 9y agoI do believe that trying to prevent the collapse of our civilization is one of the expected duties, with a high priority, of an elected official.
- macintux 9y agoThat's the key distinction between a democracy and a republic. In a republic, we expect our elected officials to be smarter than we are about how to spend money.
- Finnucane 9y agoYou find this surprising?
- macintux 9y agoI was surprised the price tag was so low.
- jerf 9y agoIt probably isn't as irrational as it sounds. I wish I still had a link to it, but I saw a more serious analysis that points out that the amount of ground an EMP nuke can cover has the radius go up linearly as the yield increases, and that the nuke that North Korea had would only be strong enough to knock out a radius of some rather small number of miles. I don't quite recall exactly but I want to say it's on the order of ten. At this point, it's pretty likely that the EMP radius of the North Korea tech is smaller than its inaccuracy if they actually tried to hit us right now, meaning they might just nuke a 10 mile radius in the ocean, or in the mountains or something. The idea that one little nuke from North Korea could take out the whole of the United States in one shot is fantasy, so defending against that is not necessarily a high priority. For further evidence for this, consider that if entire countries could be nuked back to the stone age so easily, the Cold War likely would have ended differently, and much sooner. You want to take about "taking out the entire United States" in one shot, look to the Big Nuke in the Sky. Or those targeted terrorist scenarios. (Which are still harder than they sound, honestly. Trying to coordinate such strikes such that they all go off at once without a hitch and with no possible response sounds easy to those who have never tried it, as if it's as easy as just telling everyone to fire at 11:32am or something. But there's a lot of issues between the idea and the reality. There aren't all that many instances of that working in history, and even the ones that come close still have failures, like 9/11 did.) But the simple reality is probably that it is impossible to insure society against this level of disaster. We already have 7 billion people in the world, very few of which are willing to agree that they can forgo food and water and such now to help insure against such things, and the system basically hums along at capacity. To build such hardened infrastructure would require that we raise the standard to the point that the system would then be humming along at well over capacity, which basically means in the attempt to prevent the disaster we'd be bringing the exact same disaster upon ourselves.