3 ms·
Religious fervor travels in waves. People yearn for belief, and secularism is as much a religion as a religion. The problem is without the moderating influence
by Spooky23 9y ago
Religious fervor travels in waves.
People yearn for belief, and secularism is as much a religion as a religion. The problem is without the moderating influence of less fervent believers, religions create powerful power blocs that can do all sorts of damage.
Examples abound. Look at the state of medieval Europe, bound by a reactionary catholic domination as compared to the more intellectual and cosmopolitan Middle East. Or look at the impact of the various "great awakenings" in US History.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agosecularism is as much a religion as a religion I hear that endlessly and it's just not true.
- oldandtired 9y agoDemonstrate it is not true. Religion in the very general is about who or what you serve as the core of your life. Who or what you bow down to and worship and what drives you forward. Whether this be wealth, power, influence, movie/music/sports stars, knowledge, politics, any of the many religious and philosophical belief systems (including science, including secularism).
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoThe definition of religion in the OED is "The belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, especially a personal God or gods." That pretty much excludes all your examples.
- uoaei 9y agoThis perception of religion is precisely what TFA is trying to dispel.
- cholantesh 9y agoThe first people to preach secularism were practicing Christians.
- Yizahi 9y ago> secularism is as much a religion as a religion Not even close. Inability to understand this is a distinguishing marker of religious persons (no offense, it just happens very often).
- Spooky23 9y agoIf it puts you in a camp, it's effectively the same thing.
- Yizahi 9y agoThis is exactly what I was talking about. It is not a camp, it is simply a normal state of mind, the baseline. Now religions will never ever agree with me and that is what makes us different.
- humanrebar 9y ago> Inability to understand this is a distinguishing marker of religious persons On the contrary, Christians just believe everyone trusts many things and thinks many things are true. It's not a question of "whether" you trust and think things, it's a question of "what" you trust and think. You trust medications from doctors, for example. That's believing medicine will work and that's having faith in a doctor. When a Christian talks about "faith" or "belief", they're mostly saying they think Christian theology is true and trust it to some degree. Thinking it's false and trusting other things (saving for retirement, the golden rule, "not thinking about it too much is best") is no less of a belief system. So we can come up with other words for things, I guess, but all this is fundamentally a conversation about what words mean. I think religious people know what atheists mean when they say they have no faith. I don't think it's true that atheists necessarily understand what a theist means by "everyone has a religion".
- cholantesh 9y ago>So we can come up with other words for things, I guess, but all this is fundamentally a conversation about what words mean. And secularism does not mean what a lot of religious persons think it does, as, with respect, your reply demonstrates. It's not anticlericalism or anti-theism. If it was, the vanguard of secularism would not have been composed of ardent Protestants.