5 ms·
Atheists like Sam Harris and Richard Dawkins actually undermine one of the classic arguments against religion, as they and their followers have demonstrated rep
by ZeroGravitas 9y ago
Atheists like Sam Harris and Richard Dawkins actually undermine one of the classic arguments against religion, as they and their followers have demonstrated repeatedly that the racism, sexism, xenophobia, hypocrisy, believing and repeating obvious lies, pseudoscience, favoring hierarchies with some people clearly marked as inferior, covering up for sexual assault and predation, wars etc. etc. that many would have previously associated with organised religion can bloom in atheist circles too.
I thought that might account for the low numbers of people identifying themselves as "Atheist" with a capital A, but on following the link it seems it's hard to get a straight answer on that for multiple reasons e.g.
"8% of those who call themselves atheists also say they believe in God or a universal spirit. Indeed, 2% say they are “absolutely certain” about the existence of God or a universal spirit."
- moccachino 9y agoThat you associate them with any of the things you mentioned tells me you haven't listened to or read any of their works with the intention of understanding the contents, rather than picking out sentences that can be twisted to fit into your completely wrong image of them.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoI was already an atheist and agreed with most of the points Dawkins makes in his books before I even read them. That doesn't detract from him demonstrating various human follies that could, and have been argued to be caused or exacerbated by organised religion. And if it was just one older gentlemen then you could probably just write it off, but when lots of younger atheists form communities to actively practice and promote many of these things, it really just blows that argument out of the water totally.
- moccachino 9y agoYou are confused. 1) Sam Harris / Richard Dawkins are not promoting any of these Bad Qualities (xenophobia, racism, sexism, etc.). You seem to concede that because you now talk about "lots of younger atheists" that "form communities to actively practice and promote" these Bad Qualities. Probably some exist but I haven't seen any of consequence. In any case, they are not SH/RD so your entire opening statement is therefore baseless. 2) The main argument of SH/RD is NOT that only religious people or groups promote Bad Qualities. The main argument is that religious faith is a set of made-up doctrines and "truths" that can lead to a whole variety of behaviors depending on the specific set of "truths" and doctrines. Some of those are good, many of those are bad (see Bad Qualities). The Bad Qualities arise because the faith is made-up and therefore will unavoidably have components incompatible with the real world. 3) The good parts of religion can all, each and every one, be achieved without religious faith. Sam Harris especially has been advocating this. You can have "spirituality" and meditation without all the bullcrap of gods.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoSo... 1) yes they are, that's why I named them specifically as part of a broader group of "Atheists like Sam Harris and Richard Dawkins". Here's one item where Richard Dawkins apologized for doing so: https://the-orbit.net/greta/2014/08/07/richard-dawkins-apologizes-for-dear-muslima/ https://the-orbit.net/greta/2014/08/07/richard-dawkins-apolo... 2) I never said it was the main argument, just an argument, 3) yes, I mostly of agree, but don't really see that much benefit if these non-religious people are still committing genocide based on pseudo-science or other such things. It's not the believing in nonsense part that ever really bothered me about religion, as I'm self aware enough to realise that atheists believe a lot of non-religious nonsense too.
- moccachino 9y agoI was not aware of this "Dear Muslima" thing, but let's analyze it. Someone makes a video complaining about being propositioned (I didn't watch the video but read the context). Dawkins, a homosexual who as been around for quite some time, when things were not very pleasant for them, thinks this is really not anything to complain about so he makes this remark comparing the suffering of people under a particular religion. He then apologizes for the comment. Was the comment unnecessary? Yes. Was the comment tacky? Yes. Is it indicative of sexism? I'll say not, given Dawkins' context, his previous statements and also importantly, the fact that he apologized.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoI'm fairly certain Dawkins isn't gay. He's been married to women three times. And I don't really see how telling people they're not allowed to complain about sexism unless they are the person most affected in the entire world would be made better if he was. It's a logically preposterous claim. If he truly believed it then he'd never have complained about religion, since people in other countries have it much worse than him.
- coldtea 9y ago>That you associate them with any of the things you mentioned tells me you haven't listened to or read any of their works with the intention of understanding the contents, rather than picking out sentences that can be twisted to fit into your completely wrong image of them. So similar to how they read religious texts?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- boomboomsubban 9y agoYou're bringing up a straw man version of that "classical argument," arguing that religion is the source of all bad behavior is nonsense. The Dawkins/Harris versions are more that being raised with one clear form of indoctrination opens you up to others, and that morality doesn't need or even suffers from religion.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoIf it's a straw man, why did you close with a restatement of the same thing: "morality [...] suffers from religion"? Clearly atheists can be terrible people. And collections of atheists can be terrible societies. It's certainly not a binary thing. I'd be looking for more data before concluding what kind of improvement (if any) you'd see if you removed religion totally. It would seem practical in the short term to just be against hierarchy, greed, war etc. separately from belief, rather than hope they'll all evaporate at once when religion is finally defeated. You'd likely find religious allies in most of these fights, as well as atheists on the other side.
- freeflight 9y agoNo offense, but it's hard to take anything you write seriously when you keep on misspelling atheist like that. Makes it look like you are either trying to apply some kind of meme/trolling or you might merely really need better auto-correction on your browser.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoNo offense taken, it's better auto-correction on my fingers that will be needed, and having it pointed out makes it easier to fix.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoIt's not a restatement. General morality may be worse with religion than without, but terrible acts by atheists don't disprove that as there still wouldn't be "perfect morality." Much of this argument draws from the nearly two thousand year Western belief that atheists are incapable of having morals and may not be tolerated. The general argument isn't trying to flip this around and say religion is incapable of morals, but that morals exist separately from religion and are not necessarily strengthened by religion.