6 ms·
Science, and, with one or two exceptions, scientists themselves, have no issue with religion except when it tries to suppress science.
by mannykannot 9y ago
Science, and, with one or two exceptions, scientists themselves, have no issue with religion except when it tries to suppress science.
- kgwgk 9y agoThat's like saying that science has no issues with homeopathy or telepathy except when they try to supress science.
- bbarn 9y agoWhich would also be true. Science would gladly welcome these concepts if there were a shred of evidence that they were real.
- NotAChristian 9y agoThere will come a time where science will have advanced so far that scientists will be able perform miracles that are indistinguishable from the power of God? Where Science finally converges with Spirituality because Spirituality is just really really advance science?
- mannykannot 9y agoThere are large areas of religion that are not attempting to suppress either scientific research or the propagation of its knowledge. As far as I know, believers in telepathy are not attempting to suppress science, they simply believe in something that has no scientific support.
- toflon 9y agoI think the difference is that religion focuses on what happened, and science focuses on how it happened. I know some do, but I think most Christian people don't actually believe it took god 6 days or 144 hours to create everything. I think the accept that it's a metaphor, that doesn't try to explain it. While I don't believe in any religion, I still think these two things can coexists. For instance the originator of the Big Bang theory was both a scientist and priest.
- hellrich 9y agoPolls show over 40% in the US to believe in creationism http://www.gallup.com/poll/170822/believe-creationist-view-human-origins.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/170822/believe-creationist-view-h... Also religion is not only concerned with what happened, yet often very active in prescribing what has to happen: abortion, divorce, homosexuality,...
- humanrebar 9y agoI believe the Genesis creation story. I also believe it's a metaphysical question. Given an all powerful force, of course the universe could have been created to look any way at all, including the current configuration, fossils, evolution, and all. The follow on questions are usually, "But how would God have done that and why?" Good questions, but not ultimately scientific ones. They are metaphysical and theological, respectively. EDIT: Do downvoters care to comment with their thoughts?
- tzs 9y agoWhy do you believe that particular creation story instead of one of the hundreds of other creation stories [1] from around the world? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_creation_myths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_creation_myths
- tptacek 9y agoI know you don't mean it to be, but the way you've worded that question makes it somewhat rude and very unlikely to generate the response you're hoping for.
- humanrebar 9y agoI have thicker skin than that, but not everyone does. Thanks!
- tzs 9y agoIs that because I included the Wikipedia link, and Wikipedia calls them all myths?
- alexasmyths 9y ago"That's like saying that science has no issues with homeopathy or telepathy except when they try to supress science" No, it's not. 'Homeopathy' doesn't do anything. It posits a rational framework that is simply invalid. Religions ultimately deal in matters of the 'soul' or whatever word you want to use that describes the nature we have beyond the material. If you want to accept the current 'Scientific Materialist' premise to it's full extent, then you must accept that you are a 'bag of random particles' and that there can be no 'live' 'love' 'culture' 'thought' or even 'intelligence' - after all none of those things can exist in pure randomness. We all (well, almost all) believe that we are 'alive' - implying that life is something beyond the crude material, and it's the obvious 'fail' of materialism as a workable world view. The 'trunk' of the tree of science as posited by Descartes is 'physics' - but the 'root' is metaphysics. Sometimes we forget the roots because they don't fit well into equations :) :)
- freeflight 9y agoToo bad it ain't like that the other way around: “Reason is a whore, the greatest enemy that faith has; it never comes to the aid of spiritual things, but more frequently than not struggles against the divine Word, treating with contempt all that emanates from God.” - Martin Luther
- mannykannot 9y agoLuther was probably thinking more of philosophers, whose pesky questions challenged his theology's internal logical consistency, or at least its certainty. How religion deals with such matters is its own business, though it seems to me that for the most part, religion pays little heed to analytical theology.
- humanrebar 9y ago> religion pays little heed to analytical theology What do you mean by this? There's a very strong, very cerebral theological subculture in Christianity. I think they'd raise their eyebrows to be told they aren't analytical enough. And their works aren't widely read, but they produce memes that filter through popular Christian sermons and books as time goes on. Or do you mean something specific by "analytical theology"?
- mannykannot 9y agoI meant that, when compared to the numbers of practitioners, those who actively spend much time thinking analytically about theological issues form a very small minority. It does seem that some/many/most religions go through one or more periods when the outcome of such thinking filters through to everyday observances, and that the reformation, like the Council of Nicea, was one such time. In Christianity specifically (and perhaps many other religions) there is also the tenet that faith trumps reason, which is what I think Luther was going on about in this quote.
- humanrebar 9y ago> I meant that, when compared to the numbers of practitioners, those who actively spend much time thinking analytically about theological issues form a very small minority. Somewhat, but how many people watch Transformers versus read the latest cryptocurrency paper? And there are many styles of preachers that teach and talk much like an enthusiastic college lecturer. They are very erudite and draw large audiences once a week. To talk about philosophy, ethics, morality, and critical analysis, basically. And it's really common for congregations to break out into smaller groups throughout the week to have similar self-lead conversations. > ...there is also the tenet that faith trumps reason... That may be a cultural disposition among some, but it's not a tenet. In fact, Christ himself used reason, for example, when saying, "...[a] house divided against itself will not stand." He was using deductive logic in that case to refute that he was exorcising demons as an agent of the devil.
- speedplane 9y agoThe feud between science and religion has as much to do with politics and power as it does with arguments about reason and faith.