4 ms·
In some really abstract way: that makes sense! But the problems of a widespread long term power outage sound like something a centralized preparation could cop
by emn13 9y ago
In some really abstract way: that makes sense!
But the problems of a widespread long term power outage sound like something a centralized preparation could cope with at least as effectively, if not more so; partially because it can simply be prevented appropriate preparations, and partially because even when a blackout cannot be prevented you almost certainly can ensure that recovery is relatively trivial (as compared to "rebuild transformers"). Both mitigation strategies simply aren't available to hyper-local prepper style preparations. Not to mention the fact that the population (even in the low-density US of A) is probably much higher than a prepper-tech based society can ever hope to sustain. I.e: mass prepping would likely replace famine and other catastrophes with immediate civil war, followed by famine and other catastrophes.
In abstract: Decentralization offers a remedy because it is distributed; however, the best way to make a system (more) distributed may still be via a coordinated (i.e. centralized) approach.
- FooHentai 9y agoThe optimum lies all along that spectrum I think. So combined global/centralized, localized/coordinated and individual/decentralized preparedness would give you the highest level of resilience. Defense in depth, if you will. It's also the highest effort/cost, of course. I was thinking when the parent poster hinted at that - You see that broad-spectrum approach advocated and implemented by disaster preparedness agencies - A central coordination capability coupled with regional direct response capabilities, and strong appeals from them to citizens for individual/family-level preparedness.
- emn13 9y agoThat's sane sounding. But given how poor people are at dealing with low-probability, high-impact risks, the more individual levels of risk probably should have some formal guidance and/or legal requirements imposed by the the layers higher up.