2 ms·
> The differences in means is what the Google Memo seems to focus on No it doesn't. "Mean" isn't used in this way even once in the whole memo. The only indirec
by naasking 9y ago
> The differences in means is what the Google Memo seems to focus on
No it doesn't. "Mean" isn't used in this way even once in the whole memo. The only indirect reference to means differences are two sample graphs that Damore only uses to explicitly label judgement based on means as fundamentally incorrect because it ignores significant overlap between groups. The greater male variability hypothesis is the only correct way to interpret the memo.
Further, this article's conclusion doesn't follow from the facts as presented. It's literally asserting, "I can't fathom the existence a gender-specific difference of 4SD, therefore it doesn't exist and so such a difference can't explain our observations". Didn't you miss a step where you have to actually demonstrate that this difference actually doesn't exist before you can dismiss it?
Certainly we can debate how reasonable such a distribution might be given what we know about gender-specific variability of other traits, but we absolutely can't dismiss it out of hand.
Consider, for instance, that "hiring at Google" isn't the first time this variability comes into play, but instead the Nth time, where N is fairly large. If people tend to pursue things they're naturally good at, and such variability will obviously influence what genders will be naturally inclined to pursue, on average, then this acts as a compounding filter over a decade where students are first exposed to computer science.
Consider the distribution characterizing "people's net worth". The variability in people's ability to make and save money isn't that broad, but including compounding effects of interest on debt and investments, even these small differences will yield huge variability in your net worth on your death bed.