2 ms·
> Francis Rawls has been in prison for two years now over refusing to decrypt a hard drive. People have got to stop martyrizing this guy. He's in jail because
by ajross 9y ago
> Francis Rawls has been in prison for two years now over refusing to decrypt a hard drive.
People have got to stop martyrizing this guy. He's in jail because the prosecution got a fortuitous decision that says they can hold him as long as they want until he coughs up a password. They aren't fishing for evidence, nor have they used this trick on anyone else. If he went to trial on the evidence already in public, the guy would hang (metaphorically). There is no significant doubt in anyone's mind that this drive contains CP.
But the principle is the important part you say? Sure. Make a principled argument. Don't cite this guy.
- trendia 9y ago> He's in jail because the prosecution got a fortuitous decision that says they can hold him as long as they want until he coughs up a password. You call it a fortuitous decision, I call it precedent.
- gervase 9y agoIf it's been proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the drive contains CP, then why don't they just go to trial? It seems to me that they've intentionally chosen a morally-objectionable individual upon which to build a legal precedent, as anyone who speaks in his defense can have his crime thrown back in their face. We've heard a lot about these so-called "hashes" that prove the presence of CP. It's also pretty easy to make a probabilistic proof about the likelihood of a hash collision between two non-identical files. I would venture that if you can show mathematically that you're 99.9999999% certain that the files are CP, that would qualify for "beyond a reasonable doubt". It's incontrovertible that if he's committed the crime for which he's been accused, he should be jailed. If they've already proven that crime, then why isn't he already serving his sentence? Or does the prosecution's case rest upon this one piece of evidence, and if so, is he therefore required to testify against himself in order to avoid indefinite detention?
- bodz 9y agoIt's worth noting that despite the prosecutors saying "its a foregone conclusion", they have not actually even charged Reynolds with possession of child pornography. It seems to me that while their words say they already have proof, their actions say they don't have any.