4 ms·
How about this: separate buttons for "this is a good/bad argument" and "i agree/disagree with this" then give more voice to people whose votes on these two ax
by MarkPNeyer 9y ago
How about this:
separate buttons for "this is a good/bad argument" and "i agree/disagree with this"
then give more voice to people whose votes on these two axes are orthogonal.
this rewards policing bad arguments on your side, or finding good arguments on the other side.
- rocqua 9y agoIf it is known that visibility is tied to "good/bad argument" rather than "agree/disagree", I'd expect most people to start using the 'argument' buttons for signaling their 'agreement'.
- MarkPNeyer 9y agoit's tied to both. to gain visibilty, need to vote "good argument, but i disagree" or "bad argument, but i agree with the conclusion" a naked 'good argument' or 'i agree vote' costs a small amount of karma. a 'i agree, good argument', costs a large amount of karma, because those votes should be rare.