4 ms·
> So what happens if we instead say that Google recruits from the mere mortals with Techiness scores ≥ 2SD, which is still the top 5% of all people? That ratio
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> So what happens if we instead say that Google recruits from the mere mortals with Techiness scores ≥ 2SD, which is still the top 5% of all people? That ratio drops to 1.5 to 1. Despite my enjoyment of Google’s products, I have a hard time believing they are even this selective
Being a software developer at all is ~2.5% of the US population (and even less internationally).
Moreover, if the variability hypothesis is true then the entire point is that 1SD for men will be larger in absolute terms than 1SD for women.
- tptacek 9y agoFirst, the baseline isn't the total US population. We're not surprised that toddlers and retired World War 2 veterans aren't software developers. You're looking for the percentage of the labor market, which, of course, is higher. Second, what you're pointing out is orthogonal to the question. The premise of the question is that there aren't many women software developers; the dispute between the memo and Dahly is why that is. Third, if you bring international labor into this, you muddy the issue even more, because female participation in the software development market is sharply higher in some major overseas markets. I don't follow your second sentence.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> First, the baseline isn't the total US population. We're not surprised that toddlers and retired World War 2 veterans aren't software developers. You're looking for the percentage of the labor market, which, of course, is higher. ~2.5% is the percentage of the US employed workforce. > Second, what you're pointing out is orthogonal to the question. The premise of the question is that there aren't many women software developers; the dispute between the memo and Dahly is why that is. The argument is that Google would not be excluding >95% of people, but 97.5% aren't even software developers. > Third, if you bring international labor into this, you muddy the issue even more, because female participation in the software development market is sharply higher in some major overseas markets. But why would a US employer hire foreign employees from those markets and not the world market overall? > I don't follow your second sentence. The complaint is that four standard deviations is a lot, but it's not actually four because the size of a standard deviation is not the same.