3 ms·
The problem with considering things that way is that then you can't compare countries unless they have identical economies. Suppose two countries have exactly
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
The problem with considering things that way is that then you can't compare countries unless they have identical economies.
Suppose two countries have exactly the same tax law. One of them is full of online retailers and the other is full of brick and mortar retailers. Maybe the second country has an oppressive package delivery monopoly. The brick and mortar retailers charge higher prices and have higher expenses (more employees, more real estate) and payroll and rent are deductible in both countries.
So the online retailers can make the same dollar amount of profit on lower revenue and expenses and as a result that country is considered to have a higher effective tax rate, even though their tax law is identical, because their economy is composed of a different type of companies.
And no two countries have the same economy, so you end up measuring something that can't usefully be compared with anything.
Effective tax rate as percentage of total income is a concept that originated in personal income tax, where it makes sense because the default is for expenses to not be deductible from personal income. But for business the default is the opposite. What expense is a business entity going to have that isn't a business expense? Which means that effective tax rate for a business is primarily a question of what percentage of revenue is profit.
- JamesBarney 9y agoCorporations don't care what the nominal tax rate is, they just care how big their tax bill will be if they incorporate in different jurisdictions. They care about the average and the effective. They care about the average for long term investments and the marginal-effective rate expansions of projects in countries they already operate in. And while the U.S. statutory rate is highest in the developed world by a good margin, the effective and average rates are close to top quartile.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoYou're still ignoring the fact that the effective rate depends on the company type. The US is a great market for international companies because they can hire educated US workers to design their products and then manufacture elsewhere and sell those products to US consumers, in a way that most of the profits go to offshore subsidiaries. And so we have a lot of those companies here and it brings down the average. But the US is quite horrible for small and medium sized companies who actually do pay the high nominal rates because they have no foreign subsidiaries to park profits in.
- JamesBarney 9y agoMost small to medium corporations are organized as pass through entities so they don't have to pay the corporate tax rate. Also parking profits in different companies doesn't affect the average or marginal effective tax rates because effective and average tax rates are only computed using the profit. And parking cash in offshore subsidiaries doesn't get recorded as profit for the U.S. corporation. You've argued that effective/average rates depend on the type company. But the amount you pay in taxes depends on what type of company too. So this is a feature not a bug. For instance how many buildings do you own, how much debt you have, how much and what types of equipment do you own. All of these things affect how much you pay in taxes so of course they affect average and effect tax rates but not nominal rates. My point is corporations care more about average and effective tax rates because they are more representative of what they will pay than nominal tax rates. Here is the paper which lists the methodology the CBO used. https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/115th-congress-2017-2018/reports/52419-internationaltaxratecomp.pdf https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/115th-congress-2017-2018/re...
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> Most small to medium corporations are organized as pass through entities so they don't have to pay the corporate tax rate. In which case they can't defer paying personal income tax to much the same effect. > Also parking profits in different companies doesn't affect the average or marginal effective tax rates because effective and average tax rates are only computed using the profit. They reduce their profits in the higher tax jurisdiction by paying more for products or services from a subsidiary in a lower tax jurisdiction, which lowers their effective tax rate because the cost paid to the foreign subsidiary is a deductible expense which reduces their tax burden. > You've argued that effective/average rates depend on the type company. But the amount you pay in taxes depends on what type of company too. So this is a feature not a bug. It is a bug if you are trying to compare effective tax rates between countries that have different types of companies, because you end up comparing company types instead of tax codes. > My point is corporations care more about average and effective tax rates because they are more representative of what they will pay than nominal tax rates. They obviously care about their own effective tax rate, but that may have little or nothing to do with what companies in other lines of business that represent the country's average are doing. Moreover, they care about all the details of the tax code, and make decisions based on it. High property taxes cause companies to avoid/minimize owning real property, high income/profit taxes cause companies to avoid reporting profits in that country, high consumption taxes cause companies to conserve resources or acquire them offshore, etc.