4 ms·
>But that does not indicate anything about conditions where autopilot should not be used in which it is gravely dangerous. Yes it does include those conditions
by slg 9y ago
>But that does not indicate anything about conditions where autopilot should not be used in which it is gravely dangerous.
Yes it does include those conditions because this specific accident occurred in conditions in which autopilot should not be used. That single fatality is the only one that autopilot has seen in close to one billion miles. That is an order of magnitude better than traditional fatality rates.
That leaves two possible scenarios. Either people are likely to use this system incorrectly, in which case many of those billion miles were used in poor conditions for the autopilot. Or few people are likely to use the system incorrectly, in which there is little to worry about since the autopilot system has never been involved in a reported fatality when used properly.
- felippee 9y agoHow can autopilot be involved in a fatality when used correctly, when by very definition the correct use implies alert driver who is responsible for everything that happens?
- slg 9y agoWe have both used the term "involved" and not at fault. If autopilot is on when (or immediately before) a fatality occurs, that is being involved in a fatality. The driver may be at fault in those instances if they are not alert. Although it is also possible that a separate driver is at fault and both the autopilot and Tesla driver performed adequately. For example a second driver might rear end the Tesla driver and push the car into oncoming traffic.
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 9y agoThere was another accident in China, in a controlled access divided highway where a Tesla failed to notice a maintenance vehicle moving slowly ahead on the side of the road, ended up rear-ending it and killing the driver.[1] By the way, can you point me to statistics about “traditional fatality rates” at controlled access divided highway in conditions where the line markings are clearly visible? It's dishonest to compare apples to oranges, especially given that a Tesla can't or won't recognize one from the other. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/15/business/fatal-tesla-crash-in-china-involved-autopilot-government-tv-says.html?mcubz=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/15/business/fatal-tesla-cras...