3 ms·
The real question is : does Autopilot saves more lives than it claims, as most advocates like to say? If the answer is no, then Tesla's Autopilot shouldn't be
by GuB-42 9y ago
The real question is : does Autopilot saves more lives than it claims, as most advocates like to say?
If the answer is no, then Tesla's Autopilot shouldn't be allowed as it is.
If the answer is yes, then it means that other manufacturers are too cautious.
- chillingeffect 9y agoNo that is not the real or the key question. That is your assertion. Debates about autopilot in cars have many more dimensions than simply number of deaths. There are many effects of this technology way beyond number if deaths.
- viraptor 9y agoWhat do you think are the effects of this tech that are way beyond no. of deaths?
- aidenn0 9y agoThat is a false alternative. One very simple example from a complicated issue: If Autopilot saves lives when used correctly, but Tesla's marketing material implicitly encourages people to use it incorrectly (e.g. video of Musk with no hands on the wheel), then the marketing is dangerous.
- PeterisP 9y agoThere should be no "when used correctly" - the question is whether it saves (net) lives or kills people when used normally as people tend to do for whatever reasons, no ifs or buts, just count the cases. Just as people violating laws by driving drunk still is a valid argument for more automation of driving, so people violating some guidelines by using automation incorrectly is a valid argument against it. If the automation can't handle the common misuse and still be safer on average, then it's not ready yet.
- rhino369 9y agoBut Autopilot isn't an all or nothing thing. If Tesla could save lives by changing the name, requiring constant hands on the wheel, doing a better job monitoring the person is actually in control, then they are being negligent by failing to do so. If you invent a cure for cancer, but 1/10th of your pills have rat poison that could easily have filtered out, it doesn't matter that you overall saved lives. You still killed people through negligence.
- aidenn0 9y agoThanks for saying it better than I could have.
- dkonofalski 9y agoIn this situation, though, the parallel would be more closely stated as "If you invent a cure for cancer, but 1/10000000th of your pills have rat poison, did you kill people through negligence if you acknowledged that you're in a trial period and that there's a small chance they may have a reaction and die and made them sign a waiver accepting that risk?" Every single person that uses Autopilot acknowledges the risk multiple times before they can use the system.
- pjc50 9y agoReal life is not a trolley problem. Not least because in real life you never have perfect information about what the actual probabilities are, and where products are concerned there is a long history of companies concealing vital information about product risks. (have we forgotten Feynman and the Challenger investigation? Doesn't have to be for-profit for people to mislead about risk)
- hokkos 9y agoThis is a false dichotomy, because the auto-brake system can work without autopilot, so a better of both world is possible.