3 ms·
> One is image stacking Since you seem to have experimented with this, I'd like to ask: don't you need a certain "minimum" time to capture the faintest of star
by vanderZwan 9y ago
> One is image stacking
Since you seem to have experimented with this, I'd like to ask: don't you need a certain "minimum" time to capture the faintest of stars, because their signal otherwise wouldn't rise above the noise floor? I've been curious about this with stacking in atrophotography for a while.
> The other technique is dark frame subtraction, where you take an photo with the lens covered at the same ISO/shutter/aperture as the rest of the set. Digital sensors have readout noise and heat noise which tends to be very predicable. Subtracting this noise gives you a cleaner shot as well.
For long exposures this heat noise becomes more problematic: long exposures heat up the sensor quite a bit. Have you tried building your own customised electric coolbox to keep temperatures down? It can be a fun project!
I actually used this in a different context: during long Skype sessions at home with my people abroad, my phone heats up a lot and the video would start stutter. Putting it on a cooling block actually fixes that. This had more to do with the system not having to scale back CPU performance to let the phone cool down, but a side-effect according to people on the other end of the line, was that the image quality improved too
- jxcl 9y ago> don't you need a certain "minimum" time to capture the faintest of stars, because their signal otherwise wouldn't rise above the noise floor? I'm not an expert or even very knowledgeable on image stacking, but I'll share my experience. I've taken a stacked picture of the Orion constellation. 15 exposures at 5 seconds each, and combined them to get this photo: https://www.flickr.com/photos/abliskovsky/31756623694/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/abliskovsky/31756623694/ In none of the individual exposures is the Orion Nebula visible, but in this photo it's pretty clear. So in the end I'm fairly sure that your statement is true, but the signal required is very, very faint.
- craftyguy 9y agoDo you know of any good resources for "getting into" image stacking for a complete newbie? 2 years ago I tried stacking images I took of Jupiter in my 16" dob (taken with a Canon DSLR), but it was terrible and I'm not confident I used the app I found (I think it was AstroStack..) for image stacking correctly.
- jxcl 9y agoI don't have any particular advice. I searched the web for astrophotography stacking and used some software I don't remember the name of to do it. Sorry I can't be more helpful!
- jpk 9y agoRegiStax is popular for solar and planetary imaging. I've used it several times on H-alpha solar photography. It has a fairly well defined workflow and there are lots of video tutorials on how to use it.
- craftyguy 9y agoAwesome, I will check it out. Thanks! Also looks like it runs under Wine on Linux, which is good news for me!
- vanderZwan 9y agoNice result! Ok, just for fun: I'll try to make a quick back-of-an-envelope calculation and see if we can make an educated guess... Let's use the old Sunny 16 rule, and its equivalent for moonlight, which also gives us an estimate for difference in light between day and night[0]: > Daylight (sunny day): Correct exposure for this case is given by the Sunny 16 Rule: 1 / ISO [seconds] @ f/16. So at ISO 100, a typical exposure is 1/125 @ f/16 (that's 1/3 stop less exposure than the rule calls for, but it's the closest standard shutter speed.) > Full moon: to get an equivalent exposure at night with a full moon, the rule is: 1 / ISO [days] @ f/4. That's right, DAYS. For ISO 100, that means 1/100 of a day @ f/4. > That works out to something like 14.7 minutes; I just round it up to 15 minutes. So 15 minutes @ f/4, or FOUR HOURS @ f/16. > That's 21 stops difference from sunlight to moonlight. So on a sunny day you need f/16, 100 ISO, shutter speed 1/100. flickr says you shot at f/5.6, unknown ISO (I'll go with quasi-conservative 6400 ISO), 5 seconds. Aperture increased by 1.5 stops ISO increase by 6 stops 500x longer shutter time => log2(500) -> 2^9 = 512 => bit less than 9 stops. So that's between 16-17 stops of extra light sensitivity That's five stops short of the 21 stops mentioned above. However, we're not aiming for a properly exposed single picture, we're aiming for minimum exposure to capture a signal! Even the first digital SLRs had a dynamic range of five to six stops, so theoretically should be able to capture something in the shadow regions. Nowadays ten stops is about the norm I believe, with some of the better cameras going up to twelve. So that should clearly be above the minimum signal required Also, the moonlight-rule above is very conservative: it's about exposing a scene in moonlight, not about capturing stars. Stars are light sources themselves, and probably brighter than objects reflecting moon light, even in a full moon. Also, the rule-of-thumb was based on film, which actually suffered from something called "reciprocity failure"[1] so it might exaggerate the required exposure. So yes, this should work out fine, and as your picture shows it clearly does :) [0] https://www.flickr.com/groups/11947580@N00/discuss/72157620787125918/ https://www.flickr.com/groups/11947580@N00/discuss/721576207... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reciprocity_(photography)#Reciprocity_failure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reciprocity_(photography)#Reci...
- michrassena 9y agoI don't actually know the answer to your question. My experience with image stacking is daytime landscape photography. I've found that stacking can greatly improve the shadow detail. The ETTR technique gives nice blue skies, and restrains other highlights, but naturally, with shorter exposure times, the darker portions of the scene get less exposure than they would if you allowed the skies to blow out. I'm only guessing, but there must be a minimum time for the exposure. Stacking won't change that. My assumption (and I'm not a statistician) is that the noise floor moves lower with stacking. Taking multiple images and stacking them is basically taking multiple samples. The random (Poisson shot noise) is averaged out across multiple images while the signal (the star) is a constant across the images. As you can see from the linked article, there's an amazing amount of detail that can be recovered from the shadows if you know how to get to it. In a dark sky environment, you'd be limited to the camera's sensitivity (the analog gain applied using the ISO setting), but in the city environment, almost certainly the sky light is the limiting factor. I have not experimented with custom cooling. Aside from some moon photos and photos of the recent partial (in my area) solar eclipse, I'll leave astrophotography to others.