3 ms·
> unless compelled to do so by law That's a pretty significant hedge. Also, how effective are Google's processes against dishonest employees? It would not be
by lisper 9y ago
> unless compelled to do so by law
That's a pretty significant hedge.
Also, how effective are Google's processes against dishonest employees? It would not be hard for, say, the Chinese government to plant a mole in Google's security team. (Actually, the real nightmare scenario is a Chinese mole in Intel or Apple's hardware team.)
- saalweachter 9y agoHonestly Google is one of the few companies I know of which really considers internal threats and has taken precautions to reduce the likelihood that internal bad actors will have access, to reduce the scope of access to any bad actors that slip through, and to ensure that illegitimate accesses will be noticed, reducing the time a bad actor will have access.
- lisper 9y agoI believe you. But one still has to wonder who watches the watchmen.
- saalweachter 9y agoCrazy libertarian SREs. :-P
- JadeNB 9y ago> Crazy libertarian SREs. :-P A Google search didn't immediately clarify. What is 'SRE'? The most plausible de-abbreviation I could find was "site reliability engineer".
- joshuamorton 9y agoThat'd be the right abbreviation.
- saalweachter 9y agoSite-reliability engineers is the correct de-abbreviation. While data at Google is tightly protected, everything else at Google is fairly transparent. In particular, you can see who is using what resources. SREs, among other things, monitor and manage this resource usage. Large, abnormal usages ("Why is someone copying all this data off-site?") will be noticed, and some of the people who will notice won't take "because the NSA told us to" as an acceptable answer.
- klodolph 9y agoSee the SRE book: https://landing.google.com/sre/book.html https://landing.google.com/sre/book.html
- arkem 9y agoGoogle fights against subpoenas and warrants all the time but sometimes they lose. At that point they have to comply or be held in contempt and I can't really blame Google for complying in that situation. With many thousands of engineers it is totally possible for bad actors to have infiltrated Google. It's one of the reasons why there are such strict protocols for accessing customer data or production hardware. The idea is that by default no one has access to anything and that all accesses to data and production hardware are logged and audited. I'm sure there're still opportunities for a rogue employee to do something bad but Google are way better at protecting access to their customer's data than many of the companies I've seen.
- evanlivingston 9y agoDo they fight against all subpoenas equally or do they make calls about which to fight and which to comply with? If they choose to comply with some, how do they make that call?
- CaptSpify 9y ago> Google fights against subpoenas and warrants all the time but sometimes they lose. At that point they have to comply or be held in contempt and I can't really blame Google for complying in that situation. I can and do blame them without hesitation. They could choose not to store that data, or make it zero-knowledge-based, yet they choose not to. Just because they've been compelled to hand over data via legal means does not excuse them for doing the wrong/insecure thing in the first place.