4 ms·
>I've written a few times about how the different tax rates on income, vs dividends vs interest income vs capital gains, and even business vs personal tax rates
by SilasX 9y ago
>I've written a few times about how the different tax rates on income, vs dividends vs interest income vs capital gains, and even business vs personal tax rates all work together to ensure the 1% come out ahead of the average income earning individual.
I don't think that's right. If you look at the dividends in isolation, it looks like a low tax rate. But if you ask "what's the tax rate on capital income?", then you have to adjust for the fact that, before the capital can pay out anything, the investment must pay taxes on profits (35%), taxes on dividends (15%), and taxes on undistributed gains when selling (capital gains, 15-35%).
So, trace out the taxes on a $100 investment that miraculously pays for itself and throws off $200 in profits on top and pays $50 as a dividend. I exit the position. How much was I taxed at?
$200 profits -> $70 in corporate income tax. (35%)
$50 dividend -> $7.5 dividend tax. (15%)
$115 capital gain (it retained $115 of the $200 profits, raising its market price by that much) -> $17.25 capital gains tax (15%)
Total investment (capital) income: $200.
Total capital income tax: $94.75 (17.25 + 7.5 + 70)
Total capital income tax rate: 47.3% (94.75/200).
(That understates it since you can't deduct inflation.)
And keep in mind, investment is believed to have positive externalities!
- JamesBarney 9y agoThat's the nominal corporate tax rate not the effective tax rate which is closer to 18.6%. Also you're dividing by 200 when you made 250. My calculation with those two corrections give 27.6% which is lower 13% 20018.6% + 200(1-18.6%)15% + 5015% 37.2 + 24.42 + 7.5 = 69.12 / 250 = 27.6% Marginal Tax rate for 38k-90k = 40.8% 90k-110k = 43.8% 110k - 190k - 28% 190k- 420k - 33%
- SilasX 9y ago>That's the nominal corporate tax rate not the effective tax rate which is closer to 18.6%. That's with journalist accounting where they reject valid expenses to "prove" that the tax rate is lower. >Also you're dividing by 200 when you made 250. No -- the investment paid for itself (the 100) then earned 200 (the amount above what I invested), then paid 50 out of that as a dividend. It looks strange because it doesn't make sense to tax for distributing the already-taxed profits, and yet people still think the 15% tax on the distributed part of the taxed profit is too low(!), specifically because they ignore the taxes it already had to pay -- that was the point.
- JamesBarney 9y agoOh whoops I messed up with the 250. You're right it should have been 200. The 18.6 number doesn't come from journalists though but from the CBO. And these numbers are in line with similar studies by other entities. I'm sure you agree that its not just how much your taxed on profit, but also how much profit you had to record that matters.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> I'm sure you agree that its not just how much your taxed on profit, but also how much profit you had to record that matters. If you're a retailer and you buy 1000 widgets at $9 and sell them at $10, then pay $350 in income tax, is your effective tax rate 35% or 3.5%? Can you see the problem if the government demanded 35% of total revenue instead of total profit? What you're no doubt complaining about is the fact that many of the deductions can be gamed. But that doesn't mean you can discount the legitimate ones.
- JamesBarney 9y agoA more apt analogy is imagine you are selling 1000 widgets @ $10 that you bought for $9 in two different countries. One country taxes you 20% but you can't mark down the depreciation of the building you're using so you're taxed $200 of your $1000. The other country taxes you 30% but you get to mark down the $500 depreciation of the building you're using as an expense so instead you record $500 profit. Which means you're taxed $150. You can see how even though the statutory tax rate is higher in the first country the effective tax rate is lower in the second. Different tax jurisdictions have different allowable expenses and deductions, which mean your recorded profit can be different between them. The U.S. has an especially high statutory rate, but also allows for many more deductions and expenses than other countries. The effective tax is how you take into account these differences in deductions and expenses between countries, and the U.S. has one that is in the middle of the pack.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago
- millstone 9y agoWealthy investors do not pay anything close to 47.3% on their capital gains. Looking at the statutory rates is ridiculous. It's not at all true that "before the capital can pay out anything, the investment must pay taxes on profits." Familiar examples are commodities, Bitcoin, REITs, Amazon in the 90s, carried interest. Hell, I have a friend who makes a living buying stuff at flea markets and reselling stuff on eBay - that's capital gains. But below that there's a whole industry devoted to transforming ordinary income into capital gains, like the Ernst & Young Contingent Deferred Swap (which they landed in hot water for). This is the sort of malinvestment that differential taxation encourages.
- candiodari 9y agoYes, but let's take the path of income, if you're an investor in a company. So company does work, makes gizmo, whatever, and gets out of this x, and makes costs of y. So the basis of the income of the investor is x-y, let's call that z. Ok. Most, but not all, companies would pay VAT on z. 10% in the US, 20% in Europe. That reduces the income from z to, let's call it 85% z. Then there's corporate tax. 35%. That makes it 55.25% z. The result of this is then used for dividends, which are then taxed at 15%. That makes it 46.9% z. So there's a tax rate for these investments of somewhere near 53% or so, and I bet it'll be more in practice. Also, the odds of getting an IRS audit if you have a company go up 10-fold. So the base taxes on corporate profits are higher than income taxes, no ? What am I doing wrong.