2 ms·
> There are three proposed cognitive subtypes of dyslexia (auditory, visual and attentional) In the US, unfortunately, many experts focus exclusively on the ph
by gnicholas 9y ago
> There are three proposed cognitive subtypes of dyslexia (auditory, visual and attentional)
In the US, unfortunately, many experts focus exclusively on the phonological aspects of dyslexia (which corresponds to the "auditory" description above). In other parts of the world, the understanding is broader and includes visual aspects also.
It seems that the narrower, U.S.-based conception of dyslexia goes back to some research done at Yale in 1996 [1], which is often summarized as "dyslexia is phonological, not visual". Because Americans have such a high opinion of Yale, educators/experts here like to parrot this sound bite, even if they don't fully understand the research or competing research conclusions. Researchers and experts outside the U.S. have a different view (and IMO are less influenced by a research report from Yale).
I have been especially curious about the visual impacts of dyslexia, because the technology I work [2] on is visual, and according to many people with dyslexia, it is extraordinarily helpful for them. Having heard repeatedly that "dyslexia is not visual", I was curious to know why a visual technology would have a materially beneficial effect for readers with dyslexia.
In conversations with dyslexia researchers, I have learned that there may be second-order effects of dyslexia that are visual — even if the root causes of dyslexia are not visual. Basically, people with dyslexia dislike reading and therefore do not read much. This causes them to lag on a number of reading-related skills, including visual tracking. Since visual aids can improve visual tracking, they can help readers with dyslexia, even if they don't have a type of dyslexia that was originally caused by visual differences.
1: http://dyslexia.yale.edu/Scientific_American_1996.pdf http://dyslexia.yale.edu/Scientific_American_1996.pdf
2: http://www.BeeLineReader.com http://www.BeeLineReader.com
- walshemj 9y agoThat's interesting in the UK I was diagnosed early 70's with dyslexia by my optician - who had an interest in the subject.
- gnicholas 9y agoYeah, opticians here in the U.S. would just focus on glasses/contacts. Dyslexia diagnoses here generally comes from school psychologists or literacy specialists. The standards vary — in some places it is very difficult to be diagnosed, and in other places it is very easy.