4 ms·
I don't think the problem is evaluating individual teachers. If you look at average teacher compensation it isn't that much compared to the value they add. We c
by phkahler 9y ago
I don't think the problem is evaluating individual teachers. If you look at average teacher compensation it isn't that much compared to the value they add. We could let the school and the union work out how to spread the pay among the teachers at a school, I think they're underpaid overall and that has nothing to do with evaluating them individually.
- rayiner 9y agoHow much value do they add?
- hacking_again 9y agoAll of it? None of it? Teachers themselves don't add value, teachers enable value addition.
- rayiner 9y agoI mean, obviously everyone adds value (from janitors up to doctors). And my person view is that all jobs should be compensated at the same hourly rate. But is there anything special about teachers? Like if they all quit society would go to hell, but that’s true of garbagemen and road workers too. The question is, does it matter who does the job?
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>And my person view is that all jobs should be compensated at the same hourly rate. What? Care to elaborate?
- rayiner 9y agoI think the economy should compensate people based on factors they have control over, not ones they don’t. Someone who was born smart shouldn’t be better off for his luck. Your can choose how much you work. Maybe you can choose to do things like get an education (but not in our system where that is gated by standardized tests).
- scarby 9y agoThat doesn't equate to the same hourly rate though. Different jobs have different demands. In different roles I've been both lead engineer and painted fences. If the pay was the same I would probably paint fences and write code in my spare time.
- rayiner 9y agoDid you chose to have the aptitude to write code? Why should a person who can’t write code but can paint fences get rewarded less for giving up an hour of their limited time on earth than someone who can code?
- hacking_again 9y agoI'm not saying current wages are fairly calibrated, but some work is actually more physically and/or mentally stressful per hour, and some work requires more training. Under your system, how do you prevent people from avoiding difficult work and/or work that requires extensive training? Central planning?
- harryh 9y agoI may not have chosen to have the aptitude to write code, but I did choose to go to college to better learn how to do it. I also chose to work very hard in my industry to advance. Had this come with zero financial rewards I probably wouldn't have done those things. Do you actually believe this or are you just saying something striking to illustrate an underlying principle?
- rayiner 9y ago> Do you actually believe this or are you just saying something striking to illustrate an underlying principle? It’s where I get if I’m thinking about moral justice instead of incentives/the economy. I’m not saying my proposal is workable. It’s just my observation that the last decade has been a tale of two cities for millenials. My friends who are “good at math” have been living in a different economy from everyone else.
- hacking_again 9y agoOh no, I meant teachers in general, i.e. the ones who teach. I guess broadly there's direct and indirect value adders, each group needs the other.
- noahl 9y agoYes, it matters who does the job. Good teachers have measurably better effects on students than bad ones. Here's one essay with a lot of statistics: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/12/opinion/kristof-the-value-of-teachers.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/12/opinion/kristof-the-value-... . I also remember hearing a few years ago that a good teacher can teach about twice as much in a year as an average teacher, but I'm not sure if that's the same as the 40% number from this article or something else. The effect is an especially big deal in math, because it is so cumulative. One of the worst things that can happen to a student is to have a bad math experience (whether it's the teacher, the other kids in the class, or whatever) one year, and then have future teachers never go back and cover the same material. That leaves students with permanent gaps in their knowledge, which hurts them later on.
- xiaoma 9y ago> And my person view is that all jobs should be compensated at the same hourly rate. But is there anything special about teachers? Some nations tried that idea last century. It lead to war, famine and 100 million deaths. Aiming for utopia is a noble idea, but the results have been horrific thus far.
- mercutio2 9y agoOff topic: are you, by chance, familiar with Participatory Economics [0]? Like most utopian economic visions, it’s hard to get there from here, but it seems like it’s well matched to your stated labor market ideals. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Participatory_economics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Participatory_economics
- seem_2211 9y agoThis is one of the biggest problems with trying to evaluate individual teacher performance (and reward / punish based on this evaluation), is that you need to watch out for incentives. Rewarding teachers who have best highest test scores, for example, is a pretty good way of disincentivizing good teachers from helping less gifted children. Sales people work their comp plan, especially if they're good. They tend to know what they're making and what the market pays. They tend to leave for one of 3 reasons. 1: Product isn't competitive anymore 2: Comp plan has changed 3: Company is failing / run out of funding / has pivoted and fired their entire sales team. Source: I recruit salespeople for a living.
- clort 9y ago> Rewarding teachers who have best highest test scores, for example, is a pretty good way of disincentivizing good teachers from helping less gifted children. In the UK at least, they have changed the measurement to one of progress in a basket of subjects. Students are measured as they leave primary school, and the secondary school is rated on how much different their grades are to their predicted grades. I don't know how they game that system here though, there will always be a way
- seem_2211 9y agoI actually have a friend who taught in the UK for two years. While I'd have to ask him for the specifics, he told me there was a lot of gaming the system so people would get their bonuses.