4 ms·
Not really. To be honest, the existing UX for trust relationships is hardly near optimal. Nobody needs to understand what CAs and PKIs are. I actually think the
by mehrdadn 9y ago
Not really. To be honest, the existing UX for trust relationships is hardly near optimal. Nobody needs to understand what CAs and PKIs are. I actually think the proper UI could make it pretty smooth and understandable by the layperson. All a user needs to be asked is "Whom would you trust to certify that the websites you visit are genuinely those they claim to be?" and be presented with a few reasonable options, such as perhaps (1) Default (recommended), (2) Certification companies (Verisign, Thawte, etc.), (3) Government agencies (e.g. CIA, NSA, etc.), (4) Other/Custom (advanced).
- icebraining 9y agoI think that implies there's a choice, that when you access, say, ycombinator.com, you can choose to have that site certified by one or many agencies. In reality that choice only exists for the site owner, so if you choose a subset of CAs, you'll just have HTTPS errors on a bunch of sites. If Convergence[1] ever becomes a thing, then I think your proposal makes sense, otherwise not really. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convergence_(SSL) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convergence_(SSL)
- mehrdadn 9y ago(Edit: I edited this example here to make it even simpler.) Again -- HTTPS errors are not exactly the epitome of the best UX. You could pop up a dialog saying "We can't seem to verify this site is really x.com. It might be someone else impersonating x.com. What would you like to do? [Ask Google/Microsoft] [Continue] [Cancel]" or something like that. And asking Google/Microsoft would be implemented by checking that the certificate is what they expect (so that we know it's not a MITM), whose public key they have already hopefully known about and pinned. Note: I just came up with these ideas on the spot. I believe they're much better than the current system but in no way am I suggesting they have no room for further improvement.
- hannob 9y agoHave you ever seen this picture? https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/42xxdh/what_computer_users_see_in_security_warning_boxes/ https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/42xxdh/what_computer... Because that's exactly what you're proposing.
- mehrdadn 9y agoNot that particular one, though I have seen similar, but no, that is not what I was proposing. Where is the "technical crap" in what I just suggested? Which part of it was hard to understand or make a decision on?
- bonaldi 9y agoSorry, I know it was well-meaning, but it's riddled with "technical crap" and assumed knowledge which make it hard to decide upon. Not least a pretty foreign uses of "trust" and "certification" for non-technical people. E.g.: 1. "Certified by" — what does this mean? Is like a rating thing? A tripadvisor thing for the web? 2. "X" who are they? Do they want my money? Do I need a new one? 3. "Current trusted certifier" oh god, did I choose them? Are they bad now? Did I not pay them money? Has it been hacked? Didn't it do a review of BigWebsite yet maybe? I could just wait I guess. 4. There are three buttons that say "yes"! If I hit "always" what if it was wrong? And "if Google verifies" well that's obviously a scam because my web is Google so it would already know. This is all some kind of scam. I'm out of here.
- mehrdadn 9y agoI edited it. Is this better? I honestly don't see why the concept of "This site claims to be WorldBank.com, but we can't verify this. Whom do you trust enough to ask?" requires technical knowledge of any kind. People already understand this is why they have ID cards and background checks -- "I don't know if I can trust this guy; do you trust X to run a background check (or ask him to show an ID card issued by Y)?" is the same exact concept. Why do you think ordinary people fundamentally cannot understand this on the computer when they already understand it (and much more difficult things) just fine in real life? Also, don't forget that none of this applies to when you choose the default settings. This is only if you choose to distrust some organizations.