5 ms·
It's weird this monkey is smarter than a baby but if a baby took a picture it would own the copyright. Seems kind of speciesist to me. It's kind of like the vo
by mrfusion 9y ago
It's weird this monkey is smarter than a baby but if a baby took a picture it would own the copyright.
Seems kind of speciesist to me. It's kind of like the voyager episode where the holographic doctor couldn't own the books he wrote.
- Jun8 9y agoFirst I thought no way, but turns out minors can hold copyright (https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/17320/can-a-minor-copyright-or-trademark https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/17320/can-a-minor-co...). Their rights to sue may be limited in particular states, though, it seems.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 9y agoExcept a baby probably shouldn't really hold copyright. Realistically they are not a human just legally they are. It's hard to say when human life begins but we seem to settle on treating it as after they are born. But this is nonsense in any scientific sense.
- pitaj 9y agoBabies are absolutely human, but they may not be persons depending on the definition of personhood. There is no definition of personhood.
- aaron695 9y agoOne hour before birth is it human? If so how far back do you go before it's not human, is a fertilized embryo human? If not, whats the difference post birth? We know many animals are more intelligent than babies. My point is, it's a pointless comparison. Babies don't represent anything human. And as per the monkey (in this case) can't create. It's the situation they are put in that can create the art. They are just the tool.
- slim 9y agoAs a matter of fact, the fact we consider babies human is a progressive evolution in human history. In ancient Greece for example, children were considered property of their father till the age of puberty, who could dispose of them (including of their life) the way he wishes. A father could kill his son without consequences