16 ms·
There's something very disturbing about the fact that they can collect my personal information (without my approval); profit on that info (without compensating
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
There's something very disturbing about the fact that they can collect my personal information (without my approval); profit on that info (without compensating me); and then get hacked and I have no reasonable recourse for what they've done??
How can they not be liable? How is this not negligence?
- cloakandswagger 9y agoCommon misconception. They actually do need your approval, it's just that that approval is buried in the mountains of legalese you sign whenever you sign up for a bank account, credit card or loan.
- skybrian 9y agoAlthough, in the case of identity fraud, they don't have your approval. Someone else signed the paperwork.
- _dark_matter_ 9y agoSo, if I don't want to give them my approval, I must: not sign up for a bank account, never open a credit card, avoid getting a mortgage, buy only in cash, stop renting [0], only apply to some jobs [1], not take out student loans... [0] Some landlords require credit approval [1] Some jobs check credit
- djsumdog 9y agoYou also can only buy cars from individuals (dealerships run credit checks, even if you pay with cash/check/direct draft) and you probably can't get power, water, gas or Internet in your name (you'd need a roommate and have to pay them).
- umanwizard 9y agoWhy would a dealership need to do a credit check if I showed up with a briefcase full of money to buy a car?
- jquast 9y agoBecause the patriot act. https://www.edmunds.com/car-buying/car-dealership-credit-report-scams-and-the-patriot-act.html https://www.edmunds.com/car-buying/car-dealership-credit-rep... I was also very surprised to buy a car with cash, only to have a credit check required. It's a real thing. And according to this article, not required, but dealerships are confused by the language of the law and insist on running a credit check, anyway.
- jjeaff 9y agoI think they know better, but they use it as an excuse to run your credit thus giving them more information about you as a buyer and an opportunity to sell you on their credit products (which is what they make their money on anyway).
- IncRnd 9y agoThe link you posted shows the exact opposite of what you say. The Patriot Act doesn't mandate a credit check when purchasing a car.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CryptoFascist 9y agoCan confirm. I bought a car last week in California with cash. Dealer did a credit check. The system is rotten and (short of moving country) impossible to avoid.
- ovao 9y agoWhat would've happened if your reports were frozen? Would you have been denied the car?
- seanp2k2 9y agoFYI dealers do this because they want to be able to offer you financing if your check bounces. It's also a way to ensure that you go through with the transaction because now your credit is worse and going somewhere else would lead to worse financing. Put a freeze on your accounts with the credit bureaus before you get serious about buying a car with cash. Tell them that they may not do a "hard pull" against your credit. If they try, complain to the appropriate government officials (not sure who this would be, some consumer protection agency) and take your cash elsewhere. It's a scam to lock you in to buying from them. I brought my own financing to a dealership and they wanted me to sign a thing which among other things authorized a credit check. I crossed that part out and signed it. This caused some back and forth with someone who was not in the room (basically my salesman had to go "get it approved") but they really wanted the sale because I drove a rental car down from 6 hours away just to buy this specific car (I had set the sale up ahead of time over email). I was very close to walking out and they probably knew it, and figured that they'd rather make the sale vs trying to sell me on their financing vs mine (I happened to get an extremely low rate from a credit union).
- bparsons 9y agoYes, but you really have zero choice. Unless you decide that you can live without a cell phone, rental car, credit card, mortgage or bank account the rest of your life.
- djsumdog 9y agoYou can do only burner prepaid sims that don't require a name/personal info (which is a bit difficult to find) but your general point is still very valid. You cannot escape the data collection systems in our society without going all Henry David Thoreau.
- tenpies 9y ago> You cannot escape the data collection systems in our society without going all Henry David Thoreau. Or living suspiciously like a drug dealer (without money laundering).
- jjeaff 9y agoYou can get a rental car, prepaid credit cards, and prepaid cell plans without providing your SSN. Although I'm sure a mortgage and bank account wouldn't be possible.
- skywhopper 9y agoA choice you can't say no to is no choice.
- pishpash 9y agoThese fake contracts are the bigger problem.
- Y7ZCQtNo39 9y agoIs it really a choice if it's necessary to participate in our economy? No bank or loan will offer terms that don't involve the use of one of these credit reporting agencies.
- beebmam 9y agoIt is effectively not a choice, and they take advantage of that
- cmurf 9y agoWe have all agreed. We gave permission to any company that extends credit. They give our information to these credit reporting agencies on an on-going basis, personal information, including what our payment behavior and history is. All of this comes down to trust. We trust our banks and credit card companies. They trust Equifax. Equifax's customer is your bank or credit lending company, not us. It's actually very similar to Google, et al. We aren't the consumer. They collect our personal information, vastly more than credit agencies. And the real customer are the advertisers who pay Google. The difference is, we probably trust Google more than Equifax (even before all of this). A month ago, my mom said she wanted to start using Uber on her phone. I explained how to install it, and when she did (as well as the Lyft app for that matter) it wanted access to her camera, photos, contacts, a list of information on her phone. And she said fuck no. And refused to give permission. So she still uses cabs and pays cash.
- koolba 9y agoSince when does Uber ask for use of your camera or access to photos? And for what?
- pkkim 9y agoYou can take a picture of your payment card instead of typing the digits in.
- seanp2k2 9y agoIt should ask for permission if you try to do that, not when you install the app.
- dunham 9y agoIt might be an android thing. In iOS you can ask when you need it, and still use the app if you say no. I've gotten the impression that Android asks everything up front at installation time and doesn't install if you say no, but I'm not an android user/dev so I don't know for sure.
- Iknowsecurity 9y agoThe credit system sucks. But has anybody created a better alternative yet?
- ma2rten 9y agoYes! Germany and I presume other European countries have a much better system. The main difference is that there is no magic number that any one can use to borrow money in your name. Lenders have to verify a person's identity using ID. Further more, to get loan you don't have build up a score first. You could get a margage if you have never borrowed money in your life but have a stable income.
- barsonme 9y ago> You could get a margage if you have never borrowed money in your life but have a stable income. Same in the US, although it's a bit of a pain in the ass. It's my understanding, though, (correct me if I'm wrong!) that Germany is a bit less thrilled about credit than most other countries—even in Europe.
- ma2rten 9y agoI don't think so? Germans have less credit cards, but they are still borrow money in the form of overdraft loans on their bank accounts.
- revelation 9y agoNo, they don't, just as most Americans will always pay their credit cards in full. Overdraft loans have terrible APR, as does credit from credit cards.
- cramforce 9y agoCredit management is big in Germany through SCHUFA and other companies and queried much more liberally. E.g. every time you purchase something online the store will likely check your credit and determine available payment instruments (this is pre-purchase) based on the response.
- losteric 9y agoI still hold that this shouldn't matter to consumers. My priority of problems is * When fraud happens, banks can pass the pain and burden of proof onto consumers. * Banks use insecure SSNs for authorization; some data is used for validating eligibility, authenticating the application, and authorizing the loan. * There are minimal regulations on storing different classes of personal information (We need sarbanes-oxley for auditing/accountability of aggregated personal information). If 1. was addressed, banks would have an incentive to fix 2., and force credit reporting agencies to improve 3.
- zmmmmm 9y agoAt some level I think the banks are stuck in a conflict of interest with regard to risk. The reason we need banks and credit agencies is precisely because there is risk. If transacting parties could trust each other without an intermediary we could all just trade directly and all would be fine. So banks are actually disincentivised to create a world where risk is very low. They also don't want it to be very high. They need just enough risk that it is both (a) too big a problem for us to ignore and (b) small enough of a problem that they can solve it (for a fee, of course), but finally (c) still big enough of a problem that they are relatively insulated from competition. I think it's no coincidence that the current state of affairs sits right at the sweet spot of these intersecting interests. And the problem is that the model requires an element of risk which is quite hard to control. Every now and then it flares up and becomes much bigger than they want. So we have incidents like this where the insecurities inherent in the system get exploited on a massive scale and the risk threatens to cross from profitable to massively unprofitable.
- lawpoop 9y agoI suppose at a very high level your thesis might be true, but at a practical level, I don't think it is. The banks have simply seen it's cheaper to eat the cost of fraud (and ensure the victim has the burden of proof wherever possible) than implement stricter security measures. This goes from the transaction terminal to the bank's server room. Europe has had chip cards for over 20 years. In the US, it was very recently implemented; only in the past year. It wasn't that the US banks were occupying some "sweet spot" of retail transaction risk/reward; they simply didn't want to shell out the extra bucks to send people cards with chips in them. Neither merchant nor bank wanted to pay for chip-reading terminals. So, nobody budged until just the past year. I don't know whether it was legislation, or perhaps the growing cost of credit card fraud (i.e. card skimmers, etc), but for whatever reason, it certainly wasn't a "sweet spot". We've had chip technology for 20+ years, they just didn't want to pay for it.
- xster 9y agoRecourse? Of course there are! You can subscribe to paying them protection fee that's very vague on what it actually does and that you can't unsubscribe without faxing and snail mailing them forms. Totally reasonable.
- tyingq 9y agoI suspect it will become a priority soon. Somebody is likely to pastebin the data for some cabinet members, Congresspersons, etc. Then the matter will make it to the front of the queue.
- SmirkingRevenge 9y agoWhich sadly makes it a very short list of people they actually have to compensate for their troubles.
- pishpash 9y agoIt would be nice if people actually owned all their own data (credit, medical, etc.) instead of for-profit corporations. A valid service would be to authenticate/notarize the data, perhaps, and then you'd have actual competition.
- bradleyjg 9y ago> How can they not be liable? How is this not negligence? The elements of negligence are: 1. Duty 2. Breach of Duty 3. Cause in Fact 4. Proximate Cause 5. Damages You probably haven't suffered legally cognizable damages (yet). If and when you do, they might well be liable.
- ryandrake 9y agoI'm not a lawyer, but I think it's pretty crappy that you have to show damages in order to nail someone for negligence. Shouldn't it be enough that they engaged in risky behavior? If I go out on the road and drive in a risky manner, I can end up guilty of all sorts of things without hurting anyone or damaging any property. But give up personally identifiable information (which we know leads to bank fraud) and somehow it's "show damages or GTFO".
- ryandrake 9y agoPart of it is that even the name of the crime Identity Theft insidiously paints it as something purely between the thief and the end consumer, whose identity was "stolen". Alice stole Bill's identity! But where is the company she stole it from? Where is the bank where she fraudulently used this information? These corporations' lack of accountability is built directly into the name we use for the crime! It's as if they are bystanders, peripheral to the crime. We need to bury this nebulous "Identity Theft" and call out more clearly the two specific crimes that happened: 1. negligence (the entity that gave up the info) and 2. bank fraud. When you use these terms, the companies don't get a free pass. Just change the words and they're part of the mess.
- tim333 9y agoThe bank the identity thief borrows from does suffer and is the one on the hook for the money at the end of the day. So they are kind of accountable. It's the leakers like Equifax that are not.
- irq-1 9y agoSomething an uncle said: It used to be called Bank fraud and it was the Banks problem. Now it's called Identity Theft and it's your problem.
- specialist 9y agoTreating my identity (aka personal privacy) as my personal property would help remedy this imbalance. Make a buck off my data (property), give me my cut. Allow someone to steal some portion of my identity, pay me damages. Don't want to be liable? Then don't store my data.
- jdietrich 9y agoIf you're looking for a model for better regulation, take a look at the EU's General Data Protection Regulations. It just makes sense to have a single piece of legislation that regulates the use of personal data and a single statutory regulatory agency with powers of enforcement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regula...