3 ms·
The response isn't great either. For example, the contradiction alleged in footnote 1 isn't a contradiction at all, and they don't adequately address the limita
by foldr 9y ago
The response isn't great either. For example, the contradiction alleged in footnote 1 isn't a contradiction at all, and they don't adequately address the limitations of the study in relation to the absence of non-white individuals in the dataset, or the absence accurate information about individuals' sexuality. All they do is insist without evidence that none of this makes any difference.
In fact, the original paper is deeply confused about sexual orientation:
>Their sexual orientation was established based on the gender of the partners that they were looking for (according to their profiles).
> [...]
> Another issue pertains
to the quality of the ground truth: it is possible that some of the users categorized as heterosexual
were, in fact, gay or bisexual (or vice versa). However, we believe that people voluntarily
seeking partners on the dating website have little incentive to misrepresent their sexual
orientation.
Obviously, bisexual people who say that they are looking for a partner of one or other gender are not "misrepresenting" their sexual orientation!