3 ms·
Adultery and murder have happened in just about every human society in the history of time but nobody thinks we shouldn't bother trying to suppress those impuls
by emodendroket 9y ago
Adultery and murder have happened in just about every human society in the history of time but nobody thinks we shouldn't bother trying to suppress those impulses.
- castis 9y agoMost of us would agree with you, I think what OP is saying is that it's irrational to say things like "It's 2017, who murders people anymore!?". People still murder, but we should definitely continue to try suppress that behavior.
- emodendroket 9y agoUsually a post like the OP's is a lead-in to an argument about why discrimination is actually fine and shouldn't be fought, so I guess I let my previous experiences get ahead of what the post actually says.
- colordrops 9y agoIt's more nuanced than that though. The question is where to draw the line about which behaviors are bad and which ones aren't. Things like murder are obviously bad in most cases and should be suppressed, but social structures are not so clear cut. If there aren't any clear consequences to a instinctual behavior then it's probably better to not suppress it.
- emodendroket 9y agoThere are lots of clear consequences to "tribalist" behavior, especially if we mean the obvious example of racism.
- colordrops 9y agothere are countless facets to tribalism, and racism doesn't have to be one of them. But in any case my point is more general in nature and not about tribalism.
- emodendroket 9y agoIt's really hard for me to see how you can treat "genetically similar tribes" and races as unrelated concepts.
- colordrops 9y agoThe concept of races and racism are completely orthogonal.
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, that isn't really true, since the conception of what races exist and who belongs to which shows wide cultural variation. More to the point, though, racism is an obvious manifestation of the kind of tribalism I think we are talking about and I don't think it's really controversial to argue that it is harmful at least to the marginalized groups. I'd personally even go further and say it harms all parties involved.
- freeflight 9y agoDepends on the behavior and even the consequences are not as "clear" as you make it sound because reactions to behavior can be rather subjective. Context actually matters even tho it's too often ignored these days in favor of generating drama. It's a factor way too often ignored with this issue: If "hurting people's feelings" will become a crime, then we will see no end of regulating "undesired behaviors" because people get their feelings hurt in the most subjective and unintended ways [0]. So much about "obvious examples of racism". [0] http://thedmonline.com/greek-life-retreat-ends-abruptly-bias-concerns/ http://thedmonline.com/greek-life-retreat-ends-abruptly-bias...
- emodendroket 9y agoRedlining. School segregation. Unequal economic opportunity. Disproportionate use of force in encounters with police. You get the picture. These are all negative effects of racism.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- libdong 9y agoWhen murdering someone or cheating on your partner, you probably have a lot more time to second-guess your motives. When subconsciously judging a passer-by, you don't. In my case at least, they are long gone before I even realise that I've judged someone.
- emodendroket 9y agoYeah, but that's more akin to fantasizing about someone. Actually committing adultery is more akin to, say, refusing renters based on their race.
- bluthru 9y agoI don't think you could ever make an argument that murder is good, but tribes have their benefits. For example, we know that homogenous societies have less conflict, a greater sense of community, and higher social trust.
- emodendroket 9y agoSo do smaller towns, but that doesn't seem to stop people from advocating urbanization here.
- bluthru 9y agoUrbanization doesn't necessarily regress the issues I'm talking about, especially since cities can still have their own neighborhood and block communities. Urbanization isn't unnatural and it agrees with our tribal instincts. Look at Tokyo: extremely high density with extremely small social unrest. Paris, now a collection of different tribes, can't say the same.
- emodendroket 9y agoIs that the only thing that's different about Tokyo and Paris? Beijing is over 95% Han Chinese and yet I don't think things look as harmonious. On another note, I think Japan ends up with kind of a distorted picture since so much of the crime is associated with organized criminal groups with ties to legitimate business and government operating with a degree of openness that I think would surprise most Western observers. Dubro's Yakuza book is a great primer on the topic.
- bluthru 9y ago>Is that the only thing that's different about Tokyo and Paris? I'm not claiming that. I am claiming that multiculturalism plays a role, which many people refuse to acknowledge.
- emodendroket 9y ago
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoAdultery has become vastly more socially acceptable. It isn't considered nice, but it doesn't get you killed anymore. And for murder, that can be a bit of a tautology as socially unacceptable killing is murder and anything else isn't considered on the same level as murder. But if we consider killing that isn't considered murder and if you consider forms of killing that, if not legal, are punished lighter than murder, it becomes clear that our society does allow some forms of killing others.
- emodendroket 9y agoDoes this kind of nitpicking actually invalidate the argument? Use sexual assault if you prefer. The point is that a behavior being natural or instinctual doesn't make it moral or desirable.
- BearGoesChirp 9y ago>Does this kind of nitpicking actually invalidate the argument? It does if there are enough nitpicks showing that natural behaviors are becoming more accepted because they are natural. That isn't to say they are acceptable, but they are more accepted. And this doesn't have to be true of all behaviors, because there are many factors at play. It is even possible there could be a trend where behaviors are becoming more acceptable because they are natural even if all behaviors were becoming less acceptable, if there was another stronger force acting to make all behaviors less acceptable. But if we want to get to the actual argument first presented, we would have to realize that comparing it to murder, adultery, or sexual assault is a strawman to begin with. The OP wasn't defending going around and murdering people who didn't look like you. They were saying that millions of years of evolution will influence our behaviors in small ways. It would be compared to other preferences, such as preferences in intimate partners. So, is wanting to have a specific gender, race, etc. in an intimate partner wrong? Is it socially unacceptable?
- emodendroket 9y agoThis is a philosophical question as much as anything else, but I believe that, whether we are successful in perceiving it or not, there is such a thing as objective right and wrong as distinct from social acceptability. I'm hesitant to say anything about how people should pick romantic partners, but it seems to me as though that is actually rather considerably narrowing the scope of what we're talking about. I do think it is wrong to intentionally seek to form an ethnically homogenous group of friends and associates.
- BurningFrog 9y agoAm I the only one not seeing the adultery/murder connection here?
- emodendroket 9y agoIf it is true, as is often claimed, that racism is universal and therefore fighting it is pointless or should not be done, then the same should be true of other universally-occurring antisocial behaviors.
- BurningFrog 9y agoAha. Several non obvious steps there for me :)