4 ms·
You're strawmanning. No one serious claims that there is no genetically identifiable basis for grouping people of similar geographical backgrounds. Clearly th
by ajross 9y ago
You're strawmanning. No one serious claims that there is no genetically identifiable basis for grouping people of similar geographical backgrounds. Clearly there is. Go spit in a tube and send it to 23andme, they'll tell you their guess for a mix of your ancestry.
When people say things like "race is a social construct", they mean the fact that e.g. Americans will consistently and reliably identify people with (for an example) 60% european ancestry as "black" based on things like hair nap, skin tone, clothing, language use, and behavior. Yes, these studies have been done. So if you are concerned about, say, the treatment of "black" americans by, say, the police, the field of genetics has absolutely nothing to offer to help you. Many of those people are genetically "white", as it were.
- lsd5you 9y agoI'd argue you are anti-strawmanning. As with all these debates, there is a spectrum of opinions, but plenty of high profile (if not entirely serious) people do have implicit (and even explicit) beliefs closer to the strawman than what you have outlined. Or they may agree with what you say as far as it goes but then reject any implications or further analysis based on those and similar facts.
- mathgeek 9y agoNever heard the term "anti-strawmanning" used before. Care to elaborate on the definition? Google didn't have much to say on it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- PeachPlum 9y ago> No one serious claims that there is no genetically identifiable basis for grouping people of similar geographical backgrounds. EU Council Directive 2000/43/EC of 29 June 2000 implementing the principle of equal treatment between persons irrespective of racial or ethnic origin http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32000L0043 http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:320... The European Union rejects theories which attempt to determine the existence of separate human races. The use of the term "racial origin" in this Directive does not imply an acceptance of such theories.
- ajross 9y agoThat's mostly an argument about semantics. I avoided it by using the more precise notion of "grouping people by geographic origin". And even that's wrong, because all you can really group are a bunch of gene variants. Real people intermarry. The law you cite argues against defining "race" as an actual group of real people (which is wrong, for all sorts of reasons that I assume you don't want to argue here) and not just a statistical model of gene variants (which has support and is broadly uncontroversial even among commies like me).
- PeachPlum 9y agoI posted it because you said "no-one seriously claims" and the EU is doing just that. They don't even try and justify it in the document (there may be supporting documents, they aren't referenced so I don't know). I think perhaps they don't want to say "All these people are X, all these Y". They even have to say "just because we say there are no races, doesn't mean there is no such things as racism". It would deny science to say anything but "Phenotype and some behaviours are genetically inherited, and breeders choose based on those, therefore people geographically separated are different."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]