7 ms·
If these are similar to other "uncontacted" tribes I've read about, they seem to react quite violently/aggressively when confronted (it doesn't matter if it's a
by pmarreck 9y ago
If these are similar to other "uncontacted" tribes I've read about, they seem to react quite violently/aggressively when confronted (it doesn't matter if it's a reaction to fear... if someone's shooting arrows at you first and asking questions later and you have a gun... most people are going to return fire), so if the gold miners said they either had to kill or be killed, I'm inclined to believe them unfortunately.
- papercrane 9y agoTheir self-defense claim is one thing, but it's a whole other thing to brag about it, claim to have a trophy and to have desecrated the bodies.
- pmarreck 9y agoCould be a rationalization to cope with the trauma/horror of having killed someone, similar to "inappropriate" wartime or gallows humor; depersonalizing your victim is one way to avoid the full guilt of what you did and is a common psychological coping mechanism (that's not saying it's good...)
- hsod 9y agoI admire your dedication to the principle of charity
- pmarreck 9y agoI was a Psych major. Apparently the essence of what it taught me was "empathy for others" and "intolerance for bullshit" :) I am now seemingly surrounded by the un-empathetic (and the uncritical-thinking...) Probably the one piece of information that would make one more empathetic is reading up on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attribution_bias#Fundamental_attribution_error https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attribution_bias#Fundamental_a...
- papercrane 9y ago> I am now seemingly surrounded by the un-empathetic (and the uncritical-thinking...) Then you cite fundamental attribution error... Perhaps what's really happening is other are recognizing that the statement "it was kill or be killed" is not enough to determine what exactly happened, and does not necessarily mean the miners were attacked. Even if the miners were attacked and had to kill in self-defense the other claims would still be crimes. If they were a "psychological coping mechanism", that would not absolve guilt, but only be relevant for determining punishment.
- taternuts 9y agoThe ridiculous thing is that they were allowed to go there in the first place. It's relatively common knowledge that these tribes are extremely hostile to outsiders and should be left alone, allowing gold mining there is basically signing their death warrants.
- kafkaesq 9y agoIf these are similar to other "uncontacted" tribes I've read about, they seem to react quite violently/aggressively when confronted As you would do, if a bunch of assholes started encroaching on your ancestral property. So if the gold miners said they either had to kill or be killed, I'm inclined to believe them unfortunately. No -- what they needed to do was just GTFO out of there, being as they clearly had no business being in those areas in first place. Paycheck, or "boss's orders" be damned.
- Danihan 9y agoWhy does the concept of "ancestral property" somehow suddenly make violence acceptable to you. If the bank or government forecloses on my mother's house, I can shoot whoever comes to take ownership?
- kafkaesq 9y agoIf the bank or government forecloses on my mother's house, I can shoot whoever comes to take ownership? That's clearly not a relevant analogy. Why does the concept of "ancestral property" somehow suddenly make violence acceptable to you. Look, it was the person above me who was saying, basically, that it was the miners' violence against the tribespeople that was "acceptable" (paraphrasing, but that's what they basically said). So perhaps you should take up this line of discussion with them, instead. All I'm saying is - if you knowingly invade territory known to be inhabited by an "uncontacted" community -- that is to say: by definition, a fully sovereign community, and not bound by any treaties with your own government -- and you don't expect the same kind of response (i.e. violent) any self-respecting community would make when not just their land, but their very survival comes under direct attack -- then at the very least, you're pretty damn naive. And on top of that, it becomes really, really hard to see why you might deserve any sympathy.
- Danihan 9y agoWhat if they did expect a response, and then simply answered violence with violence? Typically the person considered to be at fault is the initiator of violence.
- sprafa 9y agoyou've never been (or perhaps don't know the culture) in Brazil. Had you been you might recognize this for what it was most likely was - murder.