4 ms·
I feel very badly for the people in the article who lost their life savings on a failed investment. I also feel very badly for people who went broke on Beanie
by kstrauser 9y ago
I feel very badly for the people in the article who lost their life savings on a failed investment.
I also feel very badly for people who went broke on Beanie Babies and tulip bulbs, for almost precisely the same reasons.
Edit: I'm serious. Medallion prices peaked in 2014, well after the start of Uber and Lyft's explosion onto the spotlight. It seems like a bad idea for someone in 2006 to have invested a life's fortune in an arbitrarily limited commodity, but fiscal insanity to do the same in 2014. Those things were only ever valuable because the government issued so few of them, not because of inherent worth. When the demand for them fell below even their meager supply, they became (relatively) worthless - as predictable.
I wish the people in the article had sold their medallions to corporations in 2014 when they were still worth a mint. Failing to do so was a tragic miscalculation.
- erikb 9y agoI think this comment is bringing it to the point. Investment wise it was a bad idea to begin with, and when competitors start to hit and easily conquer the same market, then of course it becomes really stupid to invest in that market. In that regard my pity is also limited. Yes I feel their pain with them. But we also have a responsibility to investigate before making such a huge bet. And sadly if you discuss with people who lost their life savings like that, many actually think they are not responsible BECAUSE they didn't think about. The "logic" being, if you don't think about it, you can't be responsible for the result.
- skookumchuck 9y agoIt's always very risky to bet everything you have on one investment. Investments are never sure things.
- jimmaswell 9y agoCould it be comparable to going to college for a major in one field that was projected to stay lucrative but went downhill right before you were going to graduate?
- skookumchuck 9y agoI recommend to college freshmen that they select courses that are relevant to their chosen field, but also relevant to other fields. Concentrate on fundamental knowledge, not detail knowledge. For example, don't take a class that teaches how to use AutoCAD. Take a class that teaches analytical techniques.
- bsder 9y ago> I feel very badly for the people in the article who lost their life savings on a failed investment. San Diego did a good thing with this. They bought back the medallion at some price relative to what was paid minus some amount for time owned, interest, etc. Then when they redistributed those bought back medallions, they slightly increased the medallion count. That sequence stopped a lot of the problems. Anybody who got caught out by medallions collapsing could just get out. Anybody who bought in at this point knew what they were getting into.
- JamesBarney 9y agoActions like this always seems to weird to me. Given the limited resources of government and the large number of people who need help, it seems strange to ration that aid on the basis of previously making a bad financial investment.
- jacobush 9y agoIf you look at like purely a financial instrument, yes. Maybe not if you look at it like a social contract between the city administration and its populace. The aim - keep the taxi situation OK. When that medallion system started to fail, I don't think it's unreasonable for the city technocrats and or politicians to take a step back and say to themselves - OK, this is clearly not working like it used to. How can we scale back without disrupting and hurting too much those, who were partners in this (now failing) implementation of taxi regulation?
- totalZero 9y agoThe medallions exist in a government-created market. If the government offers a buy-in to a regulated business, then ceases to regulate the business in the same way, it's harming its own partners in the regulated industry. Offering to buy back the rights that it sold, well that's simply a way to reduce this harm to its partners.
- saiya-jin 9y agoso all taxpayers chipped in failed investment of few individuals who made wrong decisions. why not cover failed investments in some cryptocurrencies of others? I sure would be glad (if I would go down that risky path). I honestly don't see a difference here. people cry all the times about bailouts of banks. this is same, just scale is (much) smaller.
- user5994461 9y ago> I wish the people in the article had sold their medallions to corporations in 2014 when they were still worth a mint. Failing to do so was a tragic miscalculation. Some of the people mentioned in the articles were running corporations. They wouldn't by 2+ medallions for themselves.
- totalZero 9y agoYou shouldn't back-trade a peak in any market. Peaks always look like peaks in hindsight, but there are plenty of rallies that keep on rallying, too. Would it have been nice to sell a medallion on the 2014 highs? Sure. Is it insanity to have bought one there? No. It was simply an investment in rights to a regulated business, which has faced headwinds from unregulated competition since that time. And please keep in mind that a million dollars in NYC isn't the same as a million dollars in Iowa.
- tpxl 9y agoIt's not insane because of the high price, it's insane because of the emergence of Uber and Lyft as competitors (even if illegal).