4 ms·
> If I'm using React and I decide to sue Facebook for infringing some other software patents I hold, I lose the patent grant for any potential patents Facebook
by gnicholas 9y ago
> If I'm using React and I decide to sue Facebook for infringing some other software patents I hold, I lose the patent grant for any potential patents Facebook might hold concerning React. Which they could go after me with if they do indeed hold such patents. There's nothing proactively forcing me off React.
It seems like you're assuming that there's a decent chance that FB doesn't actually hold any patents on React. This seems unlikely, and is contradicted by what the author wrote (indicating that popular React alternatives may also infringe FB patents). Or am I not understanding your line of thinking?
My view, as a former lawyer, is that if you want to sue FB for patent infringement, you would be very unwise to continue using React. Willful infringement = treble damages.
- notacoward 9y ago> if you want to sue FB for patent infringement, you would be very unwise to continue using React. If you want to sue any company for patent infringement, you would be very unwise to continue using their software under most common licenses. The most-touted alternatives to React are plain MIT license with no patent grant at all, creating exactly the same risk. Why does the license that prevents you from being sued first get all the condemnation?
- solomatov 9y ago> The most-touted alternatives to React are plain MIT license with no patent grant at all IANAL, but as far as I understand, MIT license contains implicit patent grant.
- singron 9y agoIf these projects are covered by Facebook patents, it doesn't matter if their license has a patent grant since they don't own rights to the Facebook patents.
- kjsthree 9y agoExactly! I have yet to see a solid walkthrough of how my situation is made worse because of an explicit patent grant. I believe the fear of a grant revocation also revoking the BSD copyright license has been thoroughly settled. If that were the case that would be an issue but FB themselves have put in writing that that is not the case.
- monocasa 9y agoThat's never been tested in court, and requires some rather large leaps of thought.
- solomatov 9y agoIANAL. There's case law in copyright law concerning implicit grants. We can assume that it's at least partially applicable to patents (See here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implied_license https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implied_license).
- btown 9y agoIANAL, but this commenter, whose profile claims he is a lawyer, says BSD carries an implicit grant which is broader in theory than Facebook's explicit one, but still has some untested characteristics: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9113515 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9113515
- notacoward 9y agoIt's not just some characteristics that are unsettled. The same people braying about the legal risks of relying on an explicit but revocable patent license should be even more wary of anything implicit or assumed. Any lawyer pretending otherwise in a professional context would be flirting with malpractice.
- kjsthree 9y agoI'm not assuming they don't have any patents on React but I also have zero intention of wielding software patents so it's not something I'm concerned with. You're correct though that if one does have aims to sue Facebook they should cease using Facebook led projects. My main point is that the patent grant is nothing but gravy. Without it you have a plain Jane BSD license. Certainly not a worse situation.
- Lazare 9y ago> It seems like you're assuming that there's a decent chance that FB doesn't actually hold any patents on React. That's very likely actually. Patents are public; people have searched around for obvious concepts and phrases involving the virtual dom, synthetic events, etc., and nothing has been found. (There's also nothing novel in what React does, so you'd kind of hope there'd be no patents.) > This seems unlikely Why do you think Facebook having patents on React is likely? (Come to that, why is it any more likely than them having patents on the tech behind, say, Angular?) > and is contradicted by what the author wrote (indicating that popular React alternatives may also infringe FB patents) IF a patent on, say, the virtual DOM exists, then Preact, Vue, etc., will all violate it. But it seems fairly clear that no such patent exists. So the author is quite right; popular React alternatives almost certainly use just as many of Facebook's patents as React does...it's just the number is probably "zero".
- Vinnl 9y ago> people have searched around for obvious concepts and phrases involving the virtual dom, synthetic events, etc., and nothing has been found. Someone shared this one with me recently: https://www.google.com/patents/US20170221242 https://www.google.com/patents/US20170221242 That said, if you're using React, I don't think you should be suing Facebook for using your patents - after all, you're using theirs. If you do want to do that, then by all means, skip React.
- daenney 9y ago> That said, if you're using React, I don't think you should be suing Facebook for using your patents - after all, you're using theirs. If you do want to do that, then by all means, skip React. So if they infringe on your patents you shouldn't sue them because they let you use some of their code? Note that this covers any patent (design patents too and not just software patents) and for any reason you sue them. That's not how this is supposed to work, and precisely what's wrong with the license. The grant shouldn't be revoked if Facebook is infringing on your works. It encourages you to not litigate against them if they're in the wrong simply because you're using one of their open source components. The Apache 2 license is much better worded in this area: > If You institute patent litigation against any entity (including a cross-claim or counterclaim in a lawsuit) alleging that the Work or a Contribution incorporated within the Work constitutes direct or contributory patent infringement, then any patent licenses granted to You under this License for that Work shall terminate as of the date such litigation is filed. That Apache 2 approach is entirely fair, the grant gets terimnated if you sue for patent infringement, and only that. If that's all that Facebook wanted to protect against, as the author alledges, they could've used the Apache 2 license just fine. They didn't because they're trying to leverage their patents much further.
- JoshMnem 9y ago> My view, as a former lawyer, is that if you want to sue FB for patent infringement, you would be very unwise to continue using React. Willful infringement = treble damages. It isn't just React. The PATENTS file is in most of their repos. It seems like it will basically allow Facebook to infringe on patents from many companies once their software has crept into the dependencies of critical parts of the open source ecosystem. (I'm not sure if it would be accurate to call React Free software.)
- ergo14 9y agohttps://www.google.com/patents/US20170221242 https://www.google.com/patents/US20170221242 - It event mentions React. So maybe we should stop using the word "potentially" when it comes to React patents.
- danmaz74 9y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but this risk has nothing to do with the BSD+patent grant. If Facebook held patents on some React mechanisms, and they published React with pure BSD license, they could sue you at will if you use React. Basically, the grant guarantees that you can't be sued if you don't sue first. No grant means that you can be used in any case. Not just that, but if Facebook patents covered any similar framework (eg Vue.js) they could still sue you if you use that other framework.
- rmc 9y ago> Correct me if I'm wrong, but this risk has nothing to do with the BSD+patent grant. If Facebook held patents on some React mechanisms, and they published React with pure BSD license, they could sue you at will if you use React. I have head a theory that the BSD licence has an implicit patent grant. If FB sued you for using a plain BSD licence, you could argue the BSD covers it, if the courts agreed, you'd be fine. One objection to the BSD+Patents licence is that it sorta removed the ambiguity, and explicilty implies the BSD has no patent aspects.
- notacoward 9y ago> have head a theory that the BSD licence has an implicit patent grant Even the experts admit that it's untested, and every law student knows that anything up to an actual test in an actual court is little better than a guess. Also, beware of "experts" who aren't even talking about copyright law. For example, consider the three cases mentioned in the "US" section here. http://en.swpat.org/wiki/Implicit_patent_licence http://en.swpat.org/wiki/Implicit_patent_licence The Hewlett Packard quote is clearly about products, which I know for sure are not legally the same as licenses. The Bottom Line quote's mention of purchases casts a similar shadow. Only the De Forest quote passes even a rudimentary sniff test. The case for this implicit license is weak indeed. But fine, let's say there is such an implicit license. I have good news for you: it would apply to the Facebook code as well. The same principle used to argue for the existence of an implicit patent-license grant under plain BSD - i.e. that trying to bring a patent action would interfere with the still-operative copyright permission given in the LICENSE file - would still apply. Nothing in the PATENTS file would change that. Belt and suspenders still beats belt alone, no matter how strong or weak the "implicit license" belt might be.