5 ms·
Why is that necessarily bad? Does everyone need ongoing employment? Why can't more people build and own a business (or a robot, or other productive capital) ins
by hammock 9y ago
Why is that necessarily bad? Does everyone need ongoing employment? Why can't more people build and own a business (or a robot, or other productive capital) instead?
- lovich 9y agoThat would be great but our society, as it currently stands, is built around having a job and so people losing their jobs in large numbers is a big problem
- dangerlibrary 9y agoYou're right! More people should open independent bookstores, groceries, and gas stations like they used to. Well, maybe not those things. Maybe a car dealership? Only if Elon Musk doesn't succeed in lobbying them out of existence. Concentration of wealth leads to the ability to outcompete any small business, increasing the risk of operating independently. It's like playing blackjack in a casino. Even if you could eke out a small statistical advantage, the house can stay solvent longer than you can through volatility (and that assumes an otherwise level legal/regulatory/lobbying framework). Even Silicon Valley's startup culture implicitly acknowledges this - bootstrapped companies are a footnote. Only those companies with the financial resources of insanely wealthy investors stand a chance at mainstream success. That means the (decreasing proportion) of insanely wealthy people have a growing amount of say in what companies are allowed to succeed.
- delazeur 9y agoOnly a very tiny portion of the global population is in a position to own productive capital (or, at least, enough to support themselves). Even if the portion were higher, though, you are basically just advocating rent-seeking as the solution to job losses caused by automation, and that strikes me as dubious at best.
- rtpg 9y agoThere's a reason why "I started my company with only myself, a garage, and a $3 million dollar inheritance" is an apt description of so many founders' stories. Perhaps seizing the means of production is the way to go ;) In all seriousness though, Even starting a small business requires a decently large buffer that most people simply don't have. Hard to build one if you're surviving on mimimum wage + food stamps. Living paycheck to paycheck is a real thing. Especially if you have family
- hammock 9y agoWell, how many super wealthy people's stories are described by "I worked really hard for 45 years and got every promotion and now I have a pension and SS check"?
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoBecause Amazon, due to economy of scale, low wage employees, automation, and sheer capital can out-compete anyone - and the consumer at large will go for the best deal. It's very common, we've seen it with e.g. internet providers here; big international ISP takes over one of the major cable companies here, they invest heavily in marketing and go under the price of competitors - and thanks to billions in investment money they can keep that up for years -, the competitors lose money and customers until eventually the big one takes over. Monopoly, and then they start increasing the price again. 5-10 year plans. Amazon can do the same with businesses. Walmart, Target, etc all took local businesses and the middle class out of business when they landed in towns.
- Applejinx 9y agoI did that. My income's really closely tracked the labor share of the economy: follows all the dips and swerves and stuff. You cannot build an entrepreneurial business without a customer base.