5 ms·
Apparently the Droid X comes with extra hardware that bricks the phone if you try to root it: http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2366536,00.asp http://www.pc
by jrockway 16y ago
Apparently the Droid X comes with extra hardware that bricks the phone if you try to root it:
http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2366536,00.asp http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2366536,00.asp
http://www.mydroidworld.com/forums/droid-x-discussion/3330-how-droid-x-locked-down-let-me-tell-you-what-i-know.html http://www.mydroidworld.com/forums/droid-x-discussion/3330-h...
I wish people wouldn't do business with such consumer-unfriendly organizations. Or rather, I wish this was illegal.
- ergo98 16y agoAll recent OMAP processors have exactly the same hardware, including prior phones that don't brick when you root it.
- cookiecaper 16y agoThere is currently some controversy over this. See http://www.droid-life.com/2010/07/15/enough-with-the-efuse-talk-already/ http://www.droid-life.com/2010/07/15/enough-with-the-efuse-t... . I think the thing is that the hardware is _not_ meant to brick the phone, but there's still a dubious bootloader that kills itself when it sees a custom ROM. The good side to that is that if you can figure out how to fix the bootloader, things should work OK. I don't know, that's just what I get from that article, it's kind of hard to follow the whole thing here.
- vetinari 16y agoI don't know what specific chip is used on Droid, but I remember that on Qualcomm chipsets you cannot change primary program loader at all (it is in the chip ROM) and after the fuse is blown in handset factory, the primary program loader checks, whether the secondary program loader is signed and refuses to load it, when the check fails. So it really depends on SPL, what it allows to load and run. If it is strict in what it does, case is closed, buy something else.
- jrockway 16y agoAnd this is exactly why the GPL3 is necessary. Brick my device for modifying my GPL3 firmware? See you in court.
- wmf 16y agoOf course, that just ensures that phone vendors will never ship (and thus never contribute to) any GPLv3 software.
- jrockway 16y agoWe are a few years away from anything important being GPL3, but when that does happen, phone companies will have the choice between 1) starting out millions of man hours behind the competition or 2) letting highly-tech-savvy users install their own version of Emacs on the phone. Most will pick 2.
- gnok 16y agoMotorola's official response is that the eFuse device exists to disable the phone (aka switch to recovery mode) when unauthorized software is run, and _re-enable_ it when the original Motorola-approved software is installed. They claim that the phone is disabled only temporarily and not bricked. Source: http://www.engadget.com/2010/07/16/motorola-responds-to-droid-x-bootloader-controversy-says-efuse/ http://www.engadget.com/2010/07/16/motorola-responds-to-droi... (Sorry, I couldn't find the original Motorola post)
- makmanalp 16y agoThis looks like a bunch of FUD to me. Here's what efuse is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EFUSE http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EFUSE From wikipedia: If certain sub-systems fail, or are taking too long to respond, or are consuming too much power, the chip can instantly change its behavior by 'blowing' an eFUSE. Compare with mydroidworld: If the eFuse failes to verify this information then the eFuse receives a command to "blow the fuse" or "trip the fuse". This results in the booting process becoming corrupted and resulting in a permanent bricking of the Phone. This FailSafe is activated anytime the bootloader is tampered with or any of the above three parts of the phone has been tampered with. The second quote makes it sound like efuse was meant to be a security measure against tampering. I say, "never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity". No, it did not come with "hardware that bricks the phone if you try to root it". I think if they wanted that, they could have came up with a much cheaper solution that this sophisticated technology.
- drewcrawford 16y agoSource: I worked with efuses on a major electronic component that's statistically about 20% likely to be sitting on your desk. An efuse is basically just a low-power fuse. Think of it like a one-way switch. You can switch it to the other position exactly once, but you can't switch it back. Lots of OEMs use it for permanent storage, some of them DRM-related. Market segmentation is a common usage. Your comment is akin to a homeowner installing an alarm system. "What do these wires have to do with keeping burglars out?" and "damn wires and their electric fields, there are much less sophisticated ways of keeping burglars out". This is misinformed in two ways: 1) efuses are regularly used to prevent tampering with hardware although they can be used for other things. I say this as someone who worked on a product where they were used in just that manner. saying you can do other things with them is like saying you can peel grapes with a machete. 2) efuses are not terribly sophisticated. There's a good chance you have some on your desk right now. There are cheaper ways of doing storage, but the cheaper ways do not preserve the property that they form part of a good security system. So actually the statement is "because the system is this complicated, we know it is a security measure against tampering".
- billybob 16y agoWell, your first wish has some small fulfilment. I had been thinking of getting a Droid, but after reading about this, I no longer trust Motorola. Any idea if HTC is better?
- jrockway 16y agoI've never had any trouble rooting my HTC phones. Rooting the Sapphire involved installing an old OTA update that had a local root hole (keep writin' those OSes in C!), exploiting that hole, and overwriting the bootloader with one that doesn't care about signatures. I don’t know the technical details about the Evo 4g, but I just flashed a firmware via the official mechanism, overwrote the bootloader, and then installed the firmware I wanted. I bet HTC's deal with Google has something to do with the ease of rooting their devices.
- jsz0 16y agoHTC is also using a protected boot loader but it's possible to replace it with a non-protected loader for now. (could change in the future though) http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=725047 http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=725047
- cheald 16y agoThe Nexus One has a bootloader that can be unlocked by just sending a debug command; it's very friendly to modding. Sending that command does trip a hardware flag that voids your warranty, but actually getting custom firmware onto the device is dead easy.
- nitrogen 16y agoSo reloading the original firmware doesn't reactivate the warranty?
- cheald 16y agoCorrect. Unlocking the bootloader trips a hardware flag that says "This bootloader has been unlocked", which voids the warranty. To date, nobody has been able to figure out how to un-trip that flag, though there was a brief window in which you could hack a custom ROM onto the device without unlocking it, but that was patched out with FRF91. Personally, I think that's pretty reasonable, since third-party firmwares could potentially do things to the hardware that'd cause damage, and it's silly for hardware makers to promise to fix things caused by user negligence.
- miles 16y agohttp://stevenbird.info/2010/07/15/droidx-today-is-the-day-more-security-info/ http://stevenbird.info/2010/07/15/droidx-today-is-the-day-mo... http://nexus404.com/Blog/2010/07/16/droid-x-catches-heat-over-efuse-controversy-modders-open-source-advocates-cry-out-against-droid-x-due-to-alleged-droid-self-destruct-feature/ http://nexus404.com/Blog/2010/07/16/droid-x-catches-heat-ove...
- kragen 16y agoI wonder if it is. Are you in the US? Maybe you can buy a phone, try to upgrade the software on it, and if it bricks itself, complain to the FTC?