3 ms·
Knowledge@Wharton: Because of the way the economy was going back then, people were feeling much better, there was more money, jobs were better, salaries were be
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
Knowledge@Wharton: Because of the way the economy was going back then, people were feeling much better, there was more money, jobs were better, salaries were better. So people had that money to basically throw around.
Ferreira: It’s like today. If you ask me today who is getting more loans, riskier borrowers or the middle class, [it’s] the middle class that sees a market that’s stable, that had jobs for the past five, six years, people that were able to save for their down payment — they are the ones getting earlier into this market.
---
So we're on the cusp of repeating 2008? So soon?
- quuquuquu 9y agoIt's been almost 10 years already. That is decently long compared to bubbles of years passed. We average about one per decade. I think it makes sense. Lenders have a never ending impetus from Wall St to grow revenue and profit. When all of the rich and moneyed people (13.5m people in the USA are millionaires) have already taken on loans, who do you go to next? It becomes a cycle of just digging deeper and deeper into the question of "how do we sell this large capital asset to someone who barely has the ability to pay it back in the next 30 years". Eventually, small economic cracks (sub prime defaults) lead to medium economic cracks (minor layoffs) which eventually, if the hysteria is massive enough, lead to massive economic cracks (major layoffs, shutting down business arms, pull backs in investment) Eventually the govt is expected by market actors to become a lender of last resort, the dust settles, assets are repo'd, and over time... ... the cycle begins anew. So, keep an eye out for the cracks that may be forming right now. Soon there will be another Lehman, another Enron, another Oil Crisis, another speculative bubble bursting due to credit on credit on credit on credit.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoYes. But must we immediately repeat the same series of bad moves? Have we not learned anything?
- quuquuquu 9y agoOh, I completely agree with you! I hate bubbles, I hate predatory lending, etc. However I am very sad to say that my observation is that this is happening again, either from ignorance or deliberate action. I would love to be wrong :(
- mcguire 9y agoI suspect not, at least not in terms of a mortgage loan/housing bubble collapse. What is more worrying is a seeming disconnect between the stock market and the rest of the economy. The "middle class that sees a market that’s stable, that had jobs for the past five, six years" has been shrinking for many decades.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoHousing is up as well, yes. Based on what? The broader economy is likely worse now than circa 2007. Relatively perhaps we're not as far off as we think. The true state of the economy is the elephant in the room. Let's face it, the lack of confidence helped elect Trump. We're still warring like it's a national pastime. That's money we don't have. If it wasn't for historically ultra cheap energy (from fracking) things would be pretty ugly right now. Maybe there isn't a new bubble? But only because we never really recovered from 2008?
- AlexCoventry 9y agoIt won't be a repeat. You could argue that there are massive imbalances in the economy, but certainly they'll unleash a different kind of economic mayhem if they go awry. Also, I doubt that it's soon, and I don't think Ferreira was arguing that.