6 ms·
This puzzled me, as these Alzeheimer's and smoking results do not seem to be evidence of evolution; one would surely need to see a decrease over generations? Th
by mannykannot 9y ago
This puzzled me, as these Alzeheimer's and smoking results do not seem to be evidence of evolution; one would surely need to see a decrease over generations? The article goes on to say 'That such a large study found only two [late-acting genes] strongly suggests that evolution is “weeding” them out, says Mostafavi, and that others have probably already been purged from the population by natural selection.' The article and paper then repeat some hypotheses as to why natural selection would eliminate these hypothesized former late-acting genes from the gene pool, given that they seem to act after most people's reproductive years.
So the article and paper seem to be arguing that a low frequency of late-acting genes indicates ongoing evolution, but acknowledge that this raises questions about why natural selection would act on them.
The relevance of the decrease of the prevalence of these genes with age is apparently that survivorship bias is being used to distinguish causation from mere correlation.
- perlgeek 9y agoI had the same reaction as you at first, but read carefully: "Mostafavi and his colleagues tested more than 8 million common mutations, and found two that seemed to become less prevalent with age" Old people are less likely to have this gene than young people. This can have two possible explanations: old people with this gene are more likely to are already dead (and thus not show up in the study), or the gene is becoming more prevalent in the younger generations. The statement "People without these mutations have a survival edge and are more likely to live longer" favors the first explanation. This is not the effect of natural selection on gene prevalence. (And it would be weird for Alzheimer's, which usually occurs at an age where reproduction is often finished, and maybe even raising the kids is done already).
- mannykannot 9y agoMy apologies for editing my reply to add a third paragraph while you were replying to it, but I think that explains the relevance of the age dependence to this study: the decrease in the prevalence with age suggests that they actually do exacerbate the diseases they are associated with, and so the association is not merely a correlation. Note that they are not suggesting these genes have been the subject of selection; it is the hypothesized number of such late-acting genes that were not found that are assumed to have been selected against.
- memeCrasher 9y agoCould be that the genes have a deleterious effect in youth, not just old age.
- mannykannot 9y agoThat is one of the hypotheses advanced in the article.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoOr it could be that aging is a complex process which a naive experiment like this is unlikely to shed much light on.
- skookumchuck 9y agoAn Attenborough TV show suggested that the reason people live long compared to animals is that grandparents are needed to help raise the young. The grandparents raise the young while the parents work/hunt/farm/whatever. So having healthy grandparents gives a survival advantage.
- fauigerzigerk 9y agoThis theory is mentioned in the article as well, but it doesn't seem very plausible if we're talking about living into the 80s or 90s. At that age, the effect should be reversed as people often need care themselves rather than caring for grandchildren (who may be adults by that time anyway) I suppose the "grandmother theory" originally only explained why women live beyond menopause, not into their 70s, 80s or 90s.
- mannykannot 9y agoIncreasing longevity to the point of incapacity may be a consequence of improved health care, rather than biological adaptation.
- cpeterso 9y agoAnd while average life expectancy has been increasing for a long time (thanks to improved health care), the maximum life span has not. The oldest living people are still "only" about 115-122 years old.
- dmix 9y agoIs this because "improved health care" only makes typical illnesses treatable/prentable whereas maximum lifespan (ie, the deteriation of cells/organs/etc with age) are not being focused on? Or is it because they are very challenging things to extend?
- azernik 9y agoAlzheimer's in particular does not reduce lifespan all that much; rather, it increases the resources that children and grandchildren need to use to care for the parent. So selection against Alzheimer's would presumably (we have very little evidence for any of this) be even stronger than selection against traits that, say, killed at 70.
- freeflight 9y ago> This puzzled me, as these Alzeheimer's and smoking results do not seem to be evidence of evolution; one would surely need to see a decrease over generations? At least with smoking, we've been experiencing exactly that decrease for generations. Smoking has become vastly unpopular compared to how prevalent and socially accepted it used to be. Social factors had been one of the main driving forces, but that doesn't mean it has to be the only driving force.
- mannykannot 9y agoThe social issues complicate the problem of identifying genetic effects.