4 ms·
The thing about technological progress is that the replacement is never just "the old thing, only on computers". When people in the 90s wrote about the Internet
by jerf 16y ago
The thing about technological progress is that the replacement is never just "the old thing, only on computers". When people in the 90s wrote about the Internet and the Digital Library, quite a lot of them were envisioning something like Google Books, which is just a collection of books, only online! What actually happened was Wikipedia. (And a lot of other stuff, all of which further proves my point, but Wikipedia is sufficient.) Nobody in the 90s but the wildest visionaries saw Wikipedia coming. The Digital Library wasn't just the analog library writ large, it was something new that an analog library could never do.
Digital newspapers already exist. They are fed by RSS/Atom and do a variety of exciting things. Adding a top layer of formatting driven by a computer to make Google Reader (or your favorite RSS/Atom consumer) look like a old-style paper newspaper is a waste of time, and even worse, a waste of valuable screen space. Especially if you're going to try to write an algorithm to automatically figure out what the "top story" is, which will never be as good as a human. (And as in the first paragraph, there's also a variety of other things, like Slashdot, Reddit, HN, and all kinds of further digital elaborations on the fundamental newspaper template as modified by what digital makes easy and/or possible.)
Trying to replicate the old analog way of doing things is just silly.
- ugh 16y agoI don’t necessarily want to disagree with you, just mention that there are examples were the new thing was the old thing, only on computers. One would be digital photography. Sure, photography got a lot faster but it’s basically still the same thing. Changes have been slow and only recently began to have an impact. And I don’t think Canon or Nikon did anything wrong. I think that it was probably correct to understand digital photography as analog photography – only on computers – first and look which places you can go only after you executed that perfectly.
- jerf 16y agoThe point is not that there isn't a point of overlap, the point is that the digital world can go many more places. Every digital camera I've ever bought has come with photo manipulation software that may include various physically-inspired tools, but also goes above and beyond what can be done in analog. Any company that tried to be just "analog photos, but on computers" would be stomped in the marketplace. I have found digital photography to be a qualitatively different experience than analog photography for over a decade now. (Which isn't to say the digital experience is all pros and no cons; photography has held on to some "pros" longer than many other fields.)
- chime 16y ago> ...the new thing was the old thing, only on computers. One would be digital photography. And that led the Flickr and Photoblogs & Tumblr. Not the same thing if you ask me.
- ugh 16y agoEventually. At a time when pros were already routinely shooting with expensive digital gear that looked and worked a lot like the analog ancestor.
- felixmar 16y agoNobody in the 90s but the wildest visionaries saw Wikipedia coming Tim Berners-Lee mentioned "General reference data - encyclopaedia, etc." as the first area for intended uses of hypertext, see http://www.w3.org/DesignIssues/Uses.html http://www.w3.org/DesignIssues/Uses.html He also mentioned collaborative authoring. The innovation of Wikipedia is public editing which made sense when the general population came online.
- jerf 16y agoPretty sure Tim Berners-Lee fits under the "wildest visionary" classification. This is a compliment.
- bootload 16y ago"... Nobody in the 90s but the wildest visionaries saw Wikipedia coming ..." I bet Ward Cunningham did ~ https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Ward_Cunningham https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Ward_Cunningh... It's reported he even toyed with patenting the idea behind the Wiki in '96 ~ http://www.internetnews.com/dev-news/article.php/3648131 http://www.internetnews.com/dev-news/article.php/3648131